Nuclear Small Modular Reactors (SMRs)
Comment
Stakeholder Type

Nuclear Small Modular Reactors (SMRs)

Nuclear Small Modular Reactors (SMRs)

Case Study

Nuclear Small Modular Reactors (SMRs)

ConnectOre is an industry-wide collaboration to unlock innovation, advance responsible practices, and tackle mining industry challenges that are beyond the scope of any single organisation.
Get Involved
Published:21 Jun 2024
The transition towards net zero copper mining requires an extensive assessment of substitute energy sources. Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) have gained increasing attention as a viable alternative power source with zero-emissions. The scalability, lower initial capital investment, and enhanced safety features position SMR as an attractive option.84

SMRs are transformative in many ways, particularly when compared to large nuclear power reactors. SMRs’ contemporary designs offer inherent and passive safety features,85 which aid in mitigating hazards associated with former nuclear accidents. In February 2022, KGHM (Poland) and NuScale (USA) signed a contract to place a SMR at a KGHM copper-silver mine in 2029.86 NuScale is a miniature modularised water-cooled nuclear reactor design.87 In addition to water-cooled designs, newer SMR concepts include thorium molten salt reactors, high-temperature gas-cooled reactors, and sodium-cooled reactors.88 These future-generation designs have been built upon and advanced from the older water-cooled reactor designs, demonstrating the ever-advancing and adapting technology.

SMRs have economic viability, however, they may be considered more expensive when compared to other forms of electricity generation. NuScale, one of the leading SMR designs, targets a competitive Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE) of USD$65/MWh (USD6.5 cents/kWh).89 Comparatively, renewable energy supplies such as solar or wind power can reach LCOEs of USD$40/MWh (USD4 cents/kWh).90 In general, the csIRO GenCost 2021 - 22 report for Australia estimates large-scale solar PV and wind at around USD$35/MWh (USD3.5 cents/kWh).91 Additionally, csIRO estimates SMRs’ LCOE in 2030 to be in the range of USD$105 - $210/MWh (USD15 - 21 cents/kWh),92 notably higher than NuScale’s figures. This discrepancy requires additional clarifications; however, it is likely NuScale figures do not include operational costs or regulatory burdens associated with near-term nuclear production.

Several countries globally, including Australia, Italy, Germany, and Japan, have policies and legislation prohibiting investment in nuclear energy projects. These policies have primarily been driven by public safety concerns, waste management, and the proliferation of nuclear technology. Historical incidents such as Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, and Fukushima Daiichi strongly influence public perception of nuclear energy. Therefore, governments and regulators have placed stringent safety standards and robust frameworks for nuclear projects. SMR technology aims to address safety concerns and enhance public acceptance; however, this does not elevate regulatory restrictions immediately. International organisations are pivotal in shaping nuclear energy policies and addressing global safety standards. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) provides guidance and assistance to member states in developing and implementing nuclear power programs.93 The IAEA assists in establishing frameworks for countries to assess the feasibility and viability of SMRs by focusing on nuclear safety, security and non-proliferation.

Public acceptance and support for nuclear energy projects are essential for their success. Transparent communication, stakeholder engagement, and addressing safety and waste management concerns are imperative for creating a social licence to operate. Collaborative efforts involving government, industry, academia and research institutions, such as the Tyree Foundation of The University of NSW, can foster public understanding and acceptance of SMRs.