{
    "componentChunkName": "component---src-gatsby-entities-sub-topic-tsx",
    "path": "/sub-topics/practical-example-of-bulk-sorting-trial-1",
    "result": {"data":{"platform":{"subTopic":{"__typename":"Platform_SubTopic","_schema":{"label":"Sub Topic","pluralLabel":"Sub Topics"},"openGraph":{"title":"Practical Example of Bulk Sorting Trial","description":{"text":"The mining industry is currently investigating the application and deployment of sensor technologies that enable [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting). There is..."},"image":null},"id":"67635df3cc7194b0ec39497b","slug":"practical-example-of-bulk-sorting-trial-1","name":"Practical Example of Bulk Sorting Trial","path":"/sub-topics/practical-example-of-bulk-sorting-trial-1","outlineNumber":"2.6.4","color":{"__typename":"Platform_Color","id":"65d2ed7febf7bb9388ffab3a","slug":"core-12","name":"Core 12","value":"#3b6673","darkValue":"#2b4b56","veryDarkValue":"#1c3239"},"intro":{"id":"67635df3cc7194b0ec39497b_intro","text":"The mining industry is currently investigating the application and deployment of sensor technologies that enable [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting). There is potential for these sensing technologies to be deployed at [shovel](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_shovel), [truck](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haul_truck) and conveyor scale to enhance the resolution at which <b title=\"Stage at which final boundaries between ore and waste are calculated.\">grade control</b> decisions are applied. This improves the quality of ore delivered to mineral processing activities and increases the value of an operation."},"description":{"id":"67635df3cc7194b0ec39497b_description","text":"The evaluation of operational [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) performance is complex. Considerations must be made for the grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) present in the orebody, the preservation of this [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) as the material is mined and delivered to the sensors, the operational performance of sensing technologies and the efficiency of the sorting system. The full impact of these considerations can only be examined through <b title=\"Trials run at or near the size required for an operation.\">production scale</b> trials of [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) at operations.  \nAnglo American have developed and deployed three [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) (BOS) demonstration plants across different commodities in its <b title=\"Yielding or containing metal.\">metalliferous</b> operations, including [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena) [PGE](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinum_group) mine. [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena) is the largest [open pit](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-pit_mining) platinum mine in the world. The operation is located near the town of Mokopane, in the Waterberg district of the Limpopo province in northern South Africa. The flagship operation produced over 1.2 million ounces of platinum group elements (PGEs) in 2019 and is full owned and operated by Anglo American.  \nCurrently, there is no commercially available sensor technology capable of measuring PGEs (platinum, palladium, rhodium and gold) at the grades being mined. For this reason, [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) of [PGE](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinum_group) ores is only possible with a strong correlation to proxy elements that can be measured with available sensing technologies. At [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena), these proxy elements are nickel and copper.  \nThe sensing technologies deployed are prompt gamma neutron activation analysis ([PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis)) and [x-ray fluorescence](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) (XRF). Both sensing techniques provide non-destructive measurements of elemental grade and are available as on-belt analysers. However, the technologies differ in the way they measure grade and the speed at which they can actuate separation.\n\nCRC ORE and Anglo American have developed a systematic methodology to establish the performance of these sensor technologies and their integration within the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. This paper presents the methodology and lessons learned during the implementation of [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) and [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensors for [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena) [PGE](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinum_group) Mine.\n\nMethodology[](#Methodology)\n===========================\n\nThe following methodology for the implementation of [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena) [PGE](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinum_group) mine was developed over a series of workshops with key representatives from Anglo American, equipment suppliers and CRC ORE. While the methodology presented in this paper is specific to the application for [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena) [PGE](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinum_group) mine, variants of this methodology have been successfully applied to Anglo American <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plants at copper porphyry and nickel laterite operations in South America. The methodology covers the analysis and implementation of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> demonstration plant from conception to full production and comprises of three distinct phases:\n\n1.  Preliminary analysis – testwork and analysis to assess benefits, identify opportunities and reduce risks prior to construction and commissioning of the [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) plant;\n2.  Experimental phase – testwork to assess and optimise [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) performance during and post commissioning of the plant;\n3.  Demonstration phase – testwork to demonstrate and validate <b title=\"Trials run at or near the size required for an operation.\">production scale</b> performance of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant and its integration into routine operation.\n\nExecution of the experimental and demonstration phases were planned for the first six months of commissioning the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena). Following a successful demonstration phase, the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant will be incorporated into routine operations at site.\n\nPreliminary Analysis[](#Preliminary_Analysis)\n---------------------------------------------\n\nPreliminary analysis activities identify synergistic opportunities, reduce risks and support the decision to invest in the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. Preliminary analysis covers all activities from conception to commissioning of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant, including:\n\n*   [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) analysis of the orebody,\n*   Correlation analysis of PGEs to base metals,\n*   Selection of sensor technologies,\n*   Design, layout and equipment selection for the [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) plant,\n*   [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) analysis of the orebody,\n*   Development of a preliminary business case,\n*   Development of the experimental design and implementation plan (the methodology documented in this paper),\n*   Sample selection,\n*   Sampling strategy, and\n*   Project planning and management.\n\n### [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) analysis of the orebody[](#heterogeneity_analysis_of_the_orebody)\n\n[heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) analysis of the orebody was performed using discrete [gaussian change of support](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331624858_A_comparison_of_indirect_lognormal_and_discrete_Gaussian_change_of_support_methods_for_various_variogram_estimators/fulltext/5c83200a92851c6950640710/A-comparison-of-indirect-lognormal-and-discrete-Gaussian-change-of-support-methods-for-various-variogram-estimators.pdf?origin=publication_detail) models. This geostatistical technique uses <b title=\"Exploration and infill drill hole data (typically diamond drill core).\">resource drilling</b> data to generate <b title=\"Graph of cumulative tonnes and grade within a specific confine (e.g. pit, year etc…).\">grade-tonnage curve</b>s within an estimation <b title=\"Geological, statistical or spatial groupings used for modelling.\">domain</b> at a given selective mining unit (SMU). The volume of the<b title=\"Smallest Mining Unit (a.k.a Minimum Mining Unit MMU)\">SMU</b> can be used to estimate the scale of current <b title=\"Stage at which final boundaries between ore and waste are calculated.\">grade control</b> decisions and much smaller mining volumes approximating [truck](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haul_truck) or [shovel](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_shovel) separation. Comparison of these <b title=\"Graph of cumulative tonnes and grade within a specific confine (e.g. pit, year etc…).\">grade-tonnage curve</b>s provide an estimate of the <b title=\"Contained in unbroken ground.\">In-situ</b> grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) potential for [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) applications. However, <b title=\"Contained in unbroken ground.\">In-situ</b> estimates do not account for dilution of grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) due to mixing of material during blasting, loading, handling and stockpiling activities, nor do they account for <b title=\"Stage at which final boundaries between ore and waste are calculated.\">grade control</b> decisions that may preclude high-value ore and uneconomic <b title=\"Material determined to be below a predetermined grade or economic threshold.\">waste</b> from being treated at the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. Therefore, <b title=\"Contained in unbroken ground.\">In-situ</b> estimates of grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) are useful in identifying orebodies with potential <b title=\"Materials response to a given preconcentration technology.\">amenability</b> to [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) but may overestimate the [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) performance of the orebody.\n\n###   \nCorrelation analysis of the orebody[](#Correlation_analysis_of_the_orebody)\n\nCorrelation analysis of the orebody used <b title=\"Exploration and infill drill hole data (typically diamond drill core).\">resource drilling</b> data to assess the correlation between platinum, palladium, rhodium and gold and the correlation between these PGEs and base metals in the orebody. The analysis revealed nickel and copper as a suitable proxy for PGEs and identified <b title=\"Geological, statistical or spatial groupings used for modelling.\">domain</b>s that contain higher Ni and Cu grades and stronger correlation to PGEs to target for [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting). Similar analysis is performed to identify the use of elemental correlation within blast blocks to assist in sample selection and the development of a preliminary sorting strategy for the experimental phase.\n\n###   \nSelection of sensor technologies[](#Selection_of_sensor_technologies)\n\nSelection of sensor technologies requires a review of available sensor technologies, assessment of their fitness for purpose and confirmation by laboratory testing. This process selected separate [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) and [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) on-belt analysers for demonstration at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena).\n\n####   \nPrompt gamma neutron activation analysis ([PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis))[](#Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis_PGNAA_)\n\n[PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) is a non-destructive, elemental, penetrative analysis technique. The selected [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) emits neutrons from a live source (Californium 252) beneath the conveyor. The neutrons penetrate the mass on the conveyor belt and are absorbed into the nucleus of atoms present. The atoms are temporarily elevated to an excited state resulting in the immediate emission of a prompt gamma ray. The atom then reverts to a short-lived radioisotope that emits a slower, secondary gamma ray as it decays to a stable state. The neutron activation process is shown in Figure 1.\n\n[![FIG 1 – Neutron activation analysis](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316210/wikiore/245.png \"FIG 1 – Neutron activation analysis\")](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316210/wikiore/245.png \"FIG 1 – Neutron activation analysis\")\n\nFIG 1 – Neutron activation analysis\n\n  \n \n\nA <b title=\"Generalised term for sensors used for signal measurement\">detector</b> located above the conveyor measures the energy spectrum of the prompt gamma rays emitted from the material. The energy of the prompt gamma ray is unique to the element it came from and the grade of the elements can be correlated to the intensity of the unique gamma rays detected.\n\nNot all elements are capable of detection by [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) and detection limits restrict its application to the grade at which some elements are mined. For example, platinum is detectable but only at ultra-high grades (>5000 ppm). Nickel and copper are detectable at lower grades (>1000 ppm).\n\nThe selected [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensor has a 30 s <b title=\"Length of time for continual measurement in sensor applications before a destination is determined.\">integration time</b> which equates to an 8.3 t minimum separation unit at a <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> of 1000 tph.\n\n#### [x-ray fluorescence](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) (XRF)[](#x-ray_fluorescence_XRF_)\n\nXRF is a non-destructive, elemental, surface analysis technique that is well established in the <b title=\"Companies associated with exploration, development, operation, sale or associated sub-components.\">minerals industry</b>. The [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) on-belt analyser irradiates material on the conveyor with low-energy x-rays emitted from an x-ray tube above the belt. The emitted x-rays cause ionisation, where one or more electrons are ejected from the atom’s inner shells (Figure 2). As the electron(s) is knocked out of its orbit, a vacancy is created that makes the atom unstable. An electron from an outer orbit shell drops down and fills the void. The process continues from subsequent shells until stability of the atom is achieved. Each of these electron transitions release a fluorescent x-ray that is unique to the element and the transition between each electron shell. The energy spectrum of these fluorescent x-rays is measured by a <b title=\"Generalised term for sensors used for signal measurement\">detector</b> above the belt. The intensity of peaks in the spectrum can be correlated to the grades of the elements present in the analysed material.\n\n[![FIG 2 – The [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence|x-ray fluorescence] process (Thermo Fisher Scientific 2015)](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316212/wikiore/246.png \"FIG 2 – The [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence|x-ray fluorescence] process (Thermo Fisher Scientific 2015)\")](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316212/wikiore/246.png \"FIG 2 – The [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence|x-ray fluorescence] process (Thermo Fisher Scientific 2015)\")\n\nFIG 2 – The \\[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray\\_fluorescence|x-ray fluorescence\\] process (Thermo Fisher Scientific 2015)\n\nA key constraint with [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) is the air gap between the fluorescence event and the <b title=\"Generalised term for sensors used for signal measurement\">detector</b>, which has hindered its deployment in primary crushed or <b title=\"Post blast material in the load/haul cycle.\">run-of-mine</b> (ROM) environments. The larger the gap, the greater the reduction in signal quality. Hence, [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) measurements on a rapidly changing surface profile on a conveyor must continuously account for the distance between the surface and the <b title=\"Generalised term for sensors used for signal measurement\">detector</b>. The [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) on-belt analyser continuously measures this distance using a laser profile of the moving belt load. The selected [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) on-belt analyser has a 10 s <b title=\"Length of time for continual measurement in sensor applications before a destination is determined.\">integration time</b> which equates to a 2.8 t minimum separation unit at a <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> of 1000 tph.\n\n###   \nDesign of [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) plant[](#Design_of_bulk_ore_sorting_plant)\n\nAn image of the [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) demonstration plant is shown in Figure 3. The <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant is designed for a 1000 <b title=\"Tonnes per hour\">tph</b> capacity and consists of:\n\nA <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> [hopper](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hopper_%28particulate_collection_container%29) with [grizzly](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trommel_screen#Grizzly_screen) screen to remove <b title=\"Material above a specific size (generally used to define material that is retained on a screen deck).\">oversize</b> (>650 mm) from <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> ;  \nAn apron <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> er to control the <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> of material to the sizer, with a <b title=\"Simple screen made of perpendicular metal fingers.\">finger screen</b> to remove <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> (<100 mm) prior to the sizer and <b title=\"Particle Size Distribution\">PSD</b> analyser on plant <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> ;  \nA dual motor sizer producing a -150mm product;  \nan intermediate conveyor with <b title=\"Device used to weigh material on a conveyor belt.\">Weightometer</b>, V-plough with safety trip, [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) and [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) on-belt analyser;  \nan incline conveyor with a <b title=\"Particle Size Distribution\">PSD</b> analyser on plant product; and\n\na <b title=\"Mechanical divertors that change material flows between destinations.\">flop-gate</b> to separate <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> material to accept and divert product stackers.\n\n[![FIG 3 – ((Bulk Sorting|bulk ore sorting)) plant](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316214/wikiore/247.png \"FIG 3 – ((Bulk Sorting|bulk ore sorting)) plant\")](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316214/wikiore/247.png \"FIG 3 – ((Bulk Sorting|bulk ore sorting)) plant\")\n\nFIG 3 – ((Bulk Sorting|bulk ore sorting)) plant\n\n### [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment)[](#natural_deportment)\n\n[natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) refers to the [preferential deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) of valuable minerals to finer <b title=\"Classified material based on specific size constraints (i.e. two specific sizes).\">size fraction</b>s during <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> breakage. Understanding the [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) response across the orebody is important for two reasons. Firstly, the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant can incorporate a fixed aperture screen in the <b title=\"Mechanical divertors that change material flows between destinations.\">flop-gate</b> diversion system to recover higher grade <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> from all material treated at the plant. To determine the optimal <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b> for the <b title=\"Mechanical divertors that change material flows between destinations.\">flop-gate</b> diversion system requires assessment of the [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) response across the orebody.\n\nSecondly, the [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) response provides an indication of the risk associated with surface based [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) measurements due to [segregation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Particle_segregation) and preferential placement of <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> on the bottom of the belt. The <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant design has a <b title=\"Simple screen made of perpendicular metal fingers.\">finger screen</b> to remove -100 mm material prior to the sizer, which preferentially places <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> at the bottom of the belt and <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> r crushed material on top. If a strong [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) response is observed in the orebody, the preferential placement of high-grade <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> on the bottom of the belt could bias the grade measured by the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor.  \nThe assessment of [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) response and the potential impact on the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) measurement can be tested prior to commissioning of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. Meso-scale samples (~100kg) from <b title=\"Exit point from current pit.\">ex-pit</b> and [stockpiles](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockpile) can be collected, screened and resulting <b title=\"Classified material based on specific size constraints (i.e. two specific sizes).\">size fraction</b>s [assay](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assay)ed to determine the strength of the [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) response. Sample selection should consist of a minimum of ten samples covering each <b title=\"Geological classification of material into discrete groups.\">rock type</b>, <b title=\"Geological, statistical or spatial groupings used for modelling.\">domain</b> and stockpile for the material and grade ranges that are likely to be treated at the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant.\n\nIf samples exhibit a significant [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) response, the impact of size [segregation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Particle_segregation) on the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor can be tested by repeat analysis of the same samples with <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> on top of <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> material, <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> on top of fine material and mixed <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> and <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> material. If a systematic bias is observed, then this may be corrected in the sensor calibration. If a random bias is observed, additional testwork with the <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> bypass screen plated off during the experimental phase may be required to address the impact on [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) performance.\n\n### Sample selection[](#Sample_selection)\n\nSample selection for the experimental and demonstration phases focused on:\n\nDominant <b title=\"Geological classification of material into discrete groups.\">rock type</b>s to be mined in the short to medium term (1-5 year mine plan),  \n<b title=\"Geological, statistical or spatial groupings used for modelling.\">domain</b>s of highest Ni and Cu grades with strong correlation to PGEs,  \nPGE grade ranges of strategic significance to [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting), and  \n<b title=\"Exit point from current pit.\">ex-pit</b> material, where the location of the sample can be tracked to <b title=\"Data that has a clear position in 3d space (eg. Drill holes, GPS etc…).\">spatial data</b> (<b title=\"Digitised model of the deposit.\">resource model</b>, <b title=\"Stage at which final boundaries between ore and waste are calculated.\">grade control</b>, <b title=\"Exploration and infill drill hole data (typically diamond drill core).\">resource drilling</b> ).\n\nThis approach maximises potential opportunities for [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) in the short to medium term and the financial return of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> demonstration plant. The [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) response of stockpiled material was also assessed, as the sorting of low-grade [stockpiles](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockpile) is of strategic importance at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena). However, preference for <b title=\"Exit point from current pit.\">ex-pit</b> material of known origin in the mine allows the mapping of the sorting response of samples to <b title=\"Data that has a clear position in 3d space (eg. Drill holes, GPS etc…).\">spatial data</b>. A secondary objective to identify potential elemental markers for the differentiation of <b title=\"Geological classification of material into discrete groups.\">rock type</b>s can be examined to support [geomet](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geometallurgy)allurgical programmes and the use of the sensors to identify and separate deleterious ore types.\n\n### Sampling strategy[](#Sampling_strategy)\n\nSampling is required to calibrate, monitor and validate the performance of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant during execution of the experimental and demonstration phases of the methodology. The sampling strategy installed a secondary [crushing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) and sampling plant, to crush and [subsample](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-sampling_%28chemistry%29) all accept and divert product streams from the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. The secondary [crushing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) plant consisted of a closed-<b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> jaw and [cone crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher#Cone_crusher) producing a -12 mm product stream, that is regularly [subsample](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-sampling_%28chemistry%29)d in freefall using a rotatory vezin cutter. The [subsample](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-sampling_%28chemistry%29)d stream is crushed to -2 mm and <b title=\"Device used to separate feed material into multiple sub-samples.\">rotary split</b> to a 2kg sample for [assay](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assay).\n\n  \n \n\nExperimental Phase[](#Experimental_Phase)\n-----------------------------------------\n\nThe experimental phase commences with commissioning of <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant and is used to assess and optimises sorting performance. The experimental phase includes calibration of the sensors, proving the technology and proving the technology can drive separation decisions.\n\n### Calibration of the sensors[](#Calibration_of_the_sensors)\n\nCalibration of the sensors consists of three stages. Static calibrations are performed offline using static measurements of crushed and homogenised material. <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s are performed online by sampling and [assay](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assay)ing the <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> processed at the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. The final stage is confirmation and monitoring, where routine operations are used to confirm and monitor the calibration status of the sensors.\n\n#### Static calibration[](#Static_calibration)\n\nStatic calibration is performed by the equipment suppliers upon commissioning of the sensors and the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> intermediate conveyor. The process involves placing samples of known grade on a stationary belt under the sensors and measuring the spectra of the sample over an extended period. The samples are crushed, homogenised and represent either road base (-12mm) in the case of the XRF, or [assay](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assay) rejects (-2mm) in the case of the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis). Sample selection for static calibration must cover the grade range for normal <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b>.\n\nEach sensor also has a unique set of additional static measurements required to complete the calibration. In the case of the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensor, corrections must be made for the mass of material being measured on the belt. To do this, different belt loadings of the samples are measured statically to cover anticipated variations in the operating <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> of the plant. In the case of the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor, corrections must be made for the distance the sample is from the <b title=\"Generalised term for sensors used for signal measurement\">detector</b> when a measurement is made. This data is acquired through static measurements of the same sample at different heights on the belt.\n\nFollowing the static calibrations, the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensor can be considered partially calibrated (~20% of <b title=\"Capability of a specific piece of equipment/technology to be put into regular site operation.\">operational readiness</b> ), while the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor is considered completely calibrated.\n\n#### <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s[](#dynamic_calibrations)\n\n<b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s are performed under normal <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> using the [assay](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assay) results of samples run exclusively for <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b> and samples examined during the experimental phase. <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s capture all operational variability in belt load, <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> and material presentation to the sensors. For this reason, <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b> is the preferred calibration method for the [PGNA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis)A and used to monitor and refine the calibration of the[XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor. Sample selection for <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s should cover the grade range and <b title=\"Geological classification of material into discrete groups.\">rock type</b>s present in the deposit to identify, and calibrated for, any issues relating to the matrix effect of different material.\n\n#### Semi-dynamic confirmation of sensor calibration[](#Semi-dynamic_confirmation_of_sensor_calibration)\n\nFollowing the static calibration of the sensors, an experiment can be run to assess sensor performance by repeatedly measuring the static calibration samples on a slow-moving belt. The experiment can take place prior to the complete commissioning of the [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) plant and provides an early indication of sensor precision and accuracy. Figure 4 shows the execution of this experiment using bagged calibration samples.\n\n[![FIG 4 – Semi-dynamic confirmation of sensors using bagged calibration samples](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316217/wikiore/248.png \"FIG 4 – Semi-dynamic confirmation of sensors using bagged calibration samples\")](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316217/wikiore/248.png \"FIG 4 – Semi-dynamic confirmation of sensors using bagged calibration samples\")\n\nFIG 4 – Semi-dynamic confirmation of sensors using bagged calibration samples\n\n  \nThis experiment highlighted the differences in the <b title=\"Capability of a specific piece of equipment/technology to be put into regular site operation.\">operational readiness</b> of the sensors immediately after static calibration. The [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) produced highly variable, inaccurate measurements due to variations in belt load within each run, while the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) produced highly repeatable and accurate measurements and was able to easily distinguish transitions between high and low-grade material on the belt.\n\n### Proving the technology[](#Proving_the_technology)\n\nOnce the sensors are calibrated, the focus of the experimental phase shifts to examine how well the sensing technologies can operate under production conditions. To do this, tests are performed to establish the precision and accuracy of the sensors and the random error in sensor measurements.\n\n#### Precision and accuracy[](#Precision_and_accuracy)\n\nPrecision (repeatability) and accuracy (closeness to truth) are examined by repeatedly analysing the same parcel of material through the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. The experiment is performed without separation of product streams and prior to the product stacker conveyors installed on the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. A total of fifteen sample loops should be performed for samples covering the anticipated grade range of material treated at the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant.  \nThe process involves:  \nthe [loader](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_%28equipment%29)  <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b>ing a bucket of material into the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> [hopper](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hopper_%28particulate_collection_container%29),  \nthe [loader](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_%28equipment%29) relocating to a catching position at the discharge chutes of the elevated conveyor,  \nthe <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant running the sample through the sensors,  \nthe sample being collected in the [loader](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_%28equipment%29) bucket at the discharge chutes (Figure 5),  \nthe [loader](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_%28equipment%29) re<b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b>ing the sample into the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> [hopper](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hopper_%28particulate_collection_container%29) for the next sample loop, and  \nsecondary [crushing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) and sampling of the sample after the final loop.\n\n[![FIG 5 – [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_(equipment)|loader] in catching position for sample loops](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316221/wikiore/249.png \"FIG 5 – [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_(equipment)|loader] in catching position for sample loops\")](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316221/wikiore/249.png \"FIG 5 – [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_(equipment)|loader] in catching position for sample loops\")\n\nFIG 5 – \\[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader\\_(equipment)|loader\\] in catching position for sample loops\n\nThere were some sample losses that occurred during this process as the [loader](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_%28equipment%29) is catching the sample at the discharge chute and when the [loader](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loader_%28equipment%29) re<b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b>s the sample in the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> [hopper](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hopper_%28particulate_collection_container%29). These losses are generally greatest on the first loop, when the sample is at its <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b>st <b title=\"Particle Size Distribution\">PSD</b> and the swelling of the crushed material is greatest, resulting in bucket overflow when catching the material.\n\n#### Random error[](#Random_error)\n\nIn addition to precision and accuracy, the random error present in sensor measurements should be established. The process involves static measurements of <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> samples for at least a one-hour period to quantify the random error of the sensors. These static measurements remove any variation due to grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) within the sample and provide a guide to the minimum uncertainty in sensor measurements at the signal <b title=\"Length of time for continual measurement in sensor applications before a destination is determined.\">integration time</b> at which separation is actuated by the sensors.\n\n### Proving the technology can drive separation[](#Proving_the_technology_can_drive_separation)\n\nOnce the precision, accuracy and random error of the sensors is established, the remaining focus of experimental phase is to prove the sensors and the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant can be used to separate high and low-grade products. This is performed through several tests to examine induced and delivered [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) in the <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b>, the <b title=\"Term for operational limitations imposed within preconcentration activities.\">minimum separation capability</b> of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant and the development of yield-<b title=\"Curve generated by plotting response factors across sizes.\">Response Curve</b>s for grade categories and <b title=\"Geological, statistical or spatial groupings used for modelling.\">domain</b>s.\n\n#### Induced [heterogeneity](Heterogeneity)[](#Induced_heterogeneity)\n\n[heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) is induced in the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> by alternating <b title=\"Material void of any valuable elements.\">barren</b> waste, containing low Ni and Cu grades, with ore, containing high Ni and Cu grades. To ensure there is no incorrect material in the <b title=\"Material determined to be below a predetermined grade or economic threshold.\">waste</b> and ore samples, the material is pre-sorted. Pre-sorting is performed by running the<b title=\"Material determined to be below a predetermined grade or economic threshold.\">waste</b> sample through the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant at a low Ni and Cu [cut-off](/sub-topics/scheduling-and-cut-off-optimisation), to remove any high-grade Ni and Cu material, and the ore sample through the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant at a high Ni and Cu [cut-off](/sub-topics/scheduling-and-cut-off-optimisation), to remove low-grade Ni and Cu material. The known ore and <b title=\"Material determined to be below a predetermined grade or economic threshold.\">waste</b> samples are then alternated in the <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> to the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant. The expected outcome is a binary ore/waste signal from the sensor measurements with confirmation of separation performance by monitoring the known ore/waste being sent to the accept/divert product stackers.\n\n#### Delivered [Heterogeneity](Heterogeneity)[](#Delivered_Heterogeneity)\n\nDelivered [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) is assessed using <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> samples identified with high and low insitu grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) from spatial analysis of <b title=\"Stage at which final boundaries between ore and waste are calculated.\">grade control</b> [assay](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assay)s and models. The ability of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant to sense and separate deleterious ore types can also be assessed during this phase. Each sample is run through the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant using the sensor performance and <b title=\"Stage at which final boundaries between ore and waste are calculated.\">grade control</b> models to guide the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> [cut-off](/sub-topics/scheduling-and-cut-off-optimisation) strategy to apply to achieve an appropriate split of accept and divert streams with a strong grade differential. The accept and divert streams are collected and sent to secondary [crushing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) and sampling. Each sample should be of a sufficient volume to be representative of the <b title=\"Data that has a clear position in 3d space (eg. Drill holes, GPS etc…).\">spatial data</b> used to assess its insitu grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity). This will provide higher confidence in the [cut-off](/sub-topics/scheduling-and-cut-off-optimisation) strategy applied and the analysis and interpolation of the separation performance achieved using the <b title=\"Stage at which final boundaries between ore and waste are calculated.\">grade control</b> model.\n\n#### Minimum separation capability[](#Minimum_separation_capability)\n\nThe <b title=\"Term for operational limitations imposed within preconcentration activities.\">minimum separation capability</b> of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant is a function of the minimum <b title=\"Length of time for continual measurement in sensor applications before a destination is determined.\">integration time</b> of the sensors and the mechanical performance of the <b title=\"Mechanical divertors that change material flows between destinations.\">flop-gate</b> actuation system. The [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor reports a 10 s moving average measurement of grade every second, while the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensor’s reports an average grade every 30 s. Hence, the[XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor provides greater opportunity to separate smaller parcels of material on the belt but is likely to suffer from greater inefficiencies in the mechanical separation of those smaller parcels due to the actuation time of the <b title=\"Mechanical divertors that change material flows between destinations.\">flop-gate</b>. This experiment tests whether the separation of smaller parcels using the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor provides additional benefits. The experiment tests different [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) [cut-off](/sub-topics/scheduling-and-cut-off-optimisation)s applied to the same sample to construct yield-<b title=\"Curve generated by plotting response factors across sizes.\">Response Curve</b>s at a 15 s actuation time. These results can then be compared to the yield-<b title=\"Curve generated by plotting response factors across sizes.\">Response Curve</b>s of the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) at a 30s actuation time, using the same samples to assess whether the shorter actuation time improves separation.\n\n#### Yield-Response Curves[](#Yield-Response_Curves)\n\nThe final stage of the experimental phase develops the yield-<b title=\"Curve generated by plotting response factors across sizes.\">Response Curve</b>s of the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensor at a 30s <b title=\"Length of time for continual measurement in sensor applications before a destination is determined.\">integration time</b>. The yield-<b title=\"Curve generated by plotting response factors across sizes.\">Response Curve</b> is developed by varying the [cut-off](/sub-topics/scheduling-and-cut-off-optimisation)s applied to the sample to assess changes to the quantity and grade of the accept and divert streams. The [PGNA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis)A yield-<b title=\"Curve generated by plotting response factors across sizes.\">Response Curve</b>s should be developed using the same samples assessed in the <b title=\"Term for operational limitations imposed within preconcentration activities.\">minimum separation capability</b> of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant to provide a direct comparison between the sensor technologies and an assessment of potential benefits from a shorter integration and separation time with the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor.\n\n### Demonstration Phase[](#Demonstration_Phase)\n\nThe final phase of the [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) implementation methodology is the <b title=\"Trials run at or near the size required for an operation.\">production scale</b> demonstration of plant capacity and validation of separation performance. The initial production target for the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant is 500 tph, ramping up to demonstrate full design capacity of 1000 tph. The separation performance of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant can then be confirmed by campaign of the <b title=\"Valuable component separated from feed material in preconcentration applications.\">accept stream</b> through the processing plant. The campaign will target a minimum duration of two weeks of production capacity of the processing plant using 100% <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> <b title=\"Valuable component separated from feed material in preconcentration applications.\">accept stream</b>. The results of the demonstration phase establish the production capacity of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant, confirm its separation performance and provide confidence in the use of the high-resolution [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model) to predict <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> performance for a selected blast. To do this, a blast that exhibits favourable <b title=\"Contained in unbroken ground.\">In-situ</b> grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) and strong correlation between PGEs and Ni and Cu grade is selected and sent to the BOS. The sorting strategy to apply, and anticipated separation performance, is assessed using a high-resolution [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model) for the blast. The material is processed at the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant and regular [subsample](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-sampling_%28chemistry%29)s are collected from the accept and divert streams to monitor separation performance and avoid undesirable outcomes during the campaign. Once a sufficient quantity of the <b title=\"Valuable component separated from feed material in preconcentration applications.\">accept stream</b> is accumulated for a two-week campaign at the processing plant, the accept steam will be sent to the processing plant. The recovered metal from the <b title=\"Valuable component separated from feed material in preconcentration applications.\">accept stream</b> during the campaign, combined with the sampled grade of the divert stream, provide the final validation of <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant performance.\n\nLessons Learned[](#Lessons_Learned)\n-----------------------------------\n\nAt the time of publishing this paper, the execution of the methodology at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena) [PGE](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinum_group) mine is ongoing. However, the experiences and results to date have yield important learnings for the implementation of [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) technologies.\n\n### Timely feed back[](#Timely_feed_back)\n\nThe project has highlighted the importance of timely <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> back to monitor and validate [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) performance during the experimental and demonstration phases of implementation. Substantial delays in the commissioning of the secondary [crushing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) and sampling plant impeded the calibration of the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensor and removed the ability to identify problems and adjust the implementation plan to address these problems. As a result, there was a substantial delay in identifying crucial calibration issues with the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensor which required a large amount of retesting, further adding to time and cost of delivering the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant to production.\n\n### Sensor calibration[](#Sensor_calibration)\n\nCalibration of the sensors is fundamental to the success of [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) implementations. However, the calibration process, and resultant <b title=\"Capability of a specific piece of equipment/technology to be put into regular site operation.\">operational readiness</b>, is very different for each sensor. The calibration process for the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) is relatively simple, the majority of which can be completed offline through static calibrations of crushed and homogenised samples of known grade. After these static calibrations, the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor is considered completely calibrated. Subsequent <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s are used to monitor the calibration of the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensor.\n\nConversely, the calibration procedure for the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) requires significant sampling of analysed <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> under normal <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b>. These <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s account for typical variations in belt load and presentation of material and their impact on [PGNA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis)A measured grade. The <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s are crucial to the operational performance of the [PGNA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis)A sensor and require considerable effort and time to complete.\n\nIn the absence of <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s, the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensor displayed very strong positive correlation between analysed mass and [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) grade (Figure 6). This undesirable correlation artificially creates misleading variability in the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) measured grade due to fluctuations in plant <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b>. This resulted in erroneous separation decisions during the experimental phase and a significant amount of retesting was required.\n\n[![FIG 6 – Correlation of PGNAA Ni+Cu and analysed tonnes](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316225/wikiore/250.png \"FIG 6 – Correlation of PGNAA Ni+Cu and analysed tonnes\")](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316225/wikiore/250.png \"FIG 6 – Correlation of PGNAA Ni+Cu and analysed tonnes\")\n\nFIG 6 – Correlation of PGNAA Ni+Cu and analysed tonnes\n\nIn CRC ORE’s experience, the correlation between tonnes analysed and [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) grade is present at varying degrees for all installations of [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) technology, regardless of the supplier. The correlation is especially evident if the sensor has only been calibrated statically. This tends to be the case in [PGNA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis)A installations on the <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> conveyor to the processing plant, where the ability to perform <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b> is difficult. <b title=\"Sensor specific controls that are adjusted based on feed material types.\">dynamic calibration</b>s have been shown to significantly reduce the correlation between analysed tonnes and [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) grade but don’t seem to eliminate it completely. This highlights the importance of maintaining a consistent operational <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> to ensure accurate [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) measurement and separation in [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) applications.\n\n### Separable [heterogeneity](Heterogeneity)[](#Separable_heterogeneity)\n\nFigure 7 presents the results of the induced [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) experiment. These results were obtained by alternating the <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> of known waste, with low Ni and Cu grade, and known ore, with high Ni and Cu grade. The induced [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) results clearly demonstrate that both [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) and [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensors can measure the Ni and Cu grades present at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena) and both sensors can be used to separate material based on this measurement. However, the experiment also identified that significant mixing of material occurs in the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> [hopper](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hopper_%28particulate_collection_container%29) which degrades or neutralises the grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) present in the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b>. In order to obtain a binary ore and <b title=\"Material determined to be below a predetermined grade or economic threshold.\">waste</b> signal, the [hopper](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hopper_%28particulate_collection_container%29) had to be emptied before alternating the ore and<b title=\"Material determined to be below a predetermined grade or economic threshold.\">waste</b> <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b>. As a result, the <b title=\"Term for operational limitations imposed within preconcentration activities.\">minimum separation capability</b> of the plant is likely to be considerably larger than anticipated and the separation performance of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant is significantly less than <b title=\"Contained in unbroken ground.\">In-situ</b> grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) estimates indicate.\n\n[![FIG 7 – Induced Heterogeneity sensor readings](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316228/wikiore/251.png \"FIG 7 – Induced Heterogeneity sensor readings\")](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316228/wikiore/251.png \"FIG 7 – Induced Heterogeneity sensor readings\")\n\nFIG 7 – Induced Heterogeneity sensor readings\n\nWork is continuing to quantify the impact of mixing in the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> [hopper](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hopper_%28particulate_collection_container%29) and to examine different loading and operational philosophies to reduce this impact. However, quantifying the impact of mixing on <b title=\"Contained in unbroken ground.\">In-situ</b> [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) during blasting, loading, materials handling and stockpiling remains a critical focus for further research and the missing link between the conversion of geostatistical estimates of <b title=\"Contained in unbroken ground.\">In-situ</b> [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) to delivered [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) for [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) performance. Until this link is complete, the best estimation of [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) performance requires <b title=\"On-site test of Grade Engineering equipment (can be on/off line).\">Production Trial</b>s or sampling campaigns to establish delivered grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) present in the minimum sortable parcel size at the point of production that [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) is to be deployed.\n\n### Sensor performance[](#Sensor_performance)\n\nResults from the implementation methodology have shown the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> plant and the [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) and [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensors can detect and separate parcels of material that differ in base metal grade. The two sensors trend reasonably well, displaying consistent relative changes in <b title=\"Spatial or temporal distribution of grade.\">grade profile</b>s over a two-minute moving average (Figure 7). The precision and random error of the sensors at a common signal <b title=\"Length of time for continual measurement in sensor applications before a destination is determined.\">integration time</b> are also very similar. These findings have encouraged further investigation into the representivity of surface [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) readings across different commodities and [mineralisation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineralization_%28geology%29) styles (Rutter et al. 2020). However, the instantaneous measurements of the two sensors often display poor correlation. This is partially due to the random error of each measurement and difficulty in precisely aligning sensor data due to the lack of a common timestamp. The poor instantaneous correlation and random error of the sensors increase in significance at low-grades and complicate separation decisions that are based on these instantaneous results. Anglo American are currently investigating the fusion of these sensors, and additional sensor technologies, to optimise the sorting strategy for [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena).\n\n### Sample availability[](#Sample_availability)\n\nThe importance of sample selection cannot be overlooked. Preliminary analysis identified specific <b title=\"Geological, statistical or spatial groupings used for modelling.\">domain</b>s of the orebody that are better suited to [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting). Using this information, sample selection covered a matrix of grades, <b title=\"Geological classification of material into discrete groups.\">rock type</b>s and <b title=\"Geological, statistical or spatial groupings used for modelling.\">domain</b>s for <b title=\"Exit point from current pit.\">ex-pit</b> and stockpiled material for specific tests during the experimental phase. However, sample selection is often hampered by sample availability. It was known that not all material would be available on demand and samples were to be pre-delivered to the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> pad as they were exposed in the mine plan. Despite this, the optimum samples were not tested during the experimental phase. As a result, optimisation of the [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) strategy and synergistic opportunities to assist [geomet](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geometallurgy)allurgical classification and the ability to separate deleterious ores have been delayed.\n\nConclusions[](#Conclusions)\n---------------------------\n\nThis paper presented the methodology and lessons learned during the implementation of [PGNA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis)A and [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) sensors for [bulk ore sorting](/pages/wikiore-bulk-sorting) at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena) [PGE](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinum_group) Mine. The project had the additional challenge of sensing by proxy, requiring a strong correlation between valuable PGEs and the base metals nickel and copper. The methodology presented covers the analysis and implementation of the <b title=\"Bulk Ore Sorter\">BOS</b> demonstration plant from conception to full production. Although the application of this methodology is still being applied at [Mogalakwena](https://www.angloamerican.com/about-us/our-stories/mine-profile-mogalakwena), the experiences to date have yielded important learnings. These learnings include:\n\n*   the importance of timely <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> back from sampling and [assay](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assay) of product streams from the plant to identify problems, and develop solutions, as they occur;\n*   proper calibration of the sensors requires considerable and ongoing effort;\n*   the importance of confirming and monitoring the calibration of sensors to ensure <b title=\"Capability of a specific piece of equipment/technology to be put into regular site operation.\">operational readiness</b> prior to the commencement of experimental and demonstration testwork;\n*   the [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) and [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) sensors can detect grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) present on the conveyor, however, significant mixing occurs during material handling which reduces the grade [heterogeneity](/pages/wikiore-heterogeneity) delivered to the sensors;\n*   penetrative [PGNAA](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prompt_gamma_neutron_activation_analysis) and surface based [XRF](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_fluorescence) measurements trend reasonably well at a two-minute moving average, but instantaneous measurements have a poor correlation; and\n*   the importance of having the correct samples available during the experimental phase to optimise sorting strategy and achieve the objectives of each experiment."},"organisations":[],"embeds":{"citations":[],"imageAssets":[]},"video":null,"banner":null,"fileAssets":[],"citations":[],"feedEntries":[],"posts":[],"moderators":[]}}},"pageContext":{"lang":{"id":"en","path":"","iso":"en","name":"English","label":"English"},"availableEntities":["Catalyst","CommodityGroup","Innovation","Organisation","Page","Person","Post","SubTopic","Topic","Trend","OrganisationType","HorizonType","Economy","FeedEntry","Video","Citation","Objective","ProfileType","ExpertiseLevel"],"detailEntities":["Catalyst","CommodityGroup","Innovation","Organisation","Page","Person","Post","SubTopic","Topic","Trend"],"site":{"id":"65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","slug":"connect-ore","name":"ConnectOre","url":"https://connectore.org","title":"ConnectOre","twitter":null,"threads":null,"facebook":null,"linkedin":null,"instagram":null,"flickr":null,"tiktok":null,"youtube":null,"ownerName":"ICAA","recaptchaKey":"6LfG2J0qAAAAAHDCFfJnrWOj6DiWJGik5BAa_7p8","googleSiteVerification":null,"platformName":"ConnectOre","platformUrl":"https://platform.connectore.org","supportEmail":null,"contactEmail":null,"mainMenu":{"id":"65d2edaaebf7bb9388ffaf79","slug":"website-navigation"},"linearMenu":null,"entityViews":[{"id":"67528c24c135ebcfc668f1ba_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Value Chain","hash":"value-chain","label":null,"slug":"value-chain","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"6752a61b8b51dfa7b77b1e37","name":"Connections Navigator Icon Glyph","slug":"connections-navigator-icon-glyph","component":"ConnectionsNavigatorIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"6667fa4ff794dd6e045135c1","name":"Value Chain Theme","internalName":"Trend"},{"id":"6667fa58f794dd6e045135c6","name":"Topic","internalName":"Topic"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"6757ef1ede8adbd45cf19474_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Bulletin Board","hash":"bulletin-board","label":null,"slug":"bulletin-board","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"681c2cebbccc5a72d8382f31","name":"Tag Icon","slug":"tag-icon","component":"TagDotIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"67528d88c135ebcfc668f31b_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Innovations","hash":"innovations","label":null,"slug":"innovations","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"67528cddc135ebcfc668f304","name":"Grid Icon Glyph","slug":"grid-icon-glyph","component":"GridIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"67528d74c135ebcfc668f315","name":"Innovation","internalName":"innovation"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"67625640fbc7c50d8644c592_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Community","hash":"community","label":null,"slug":"community","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"67528cddc135ebcfc668f304","name":"Grid Icon Glyph","slug":"grid-icon-glyph","component":"GridIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"67528404c135ebcfc668ee1c","name":"Person","internalName":"Person"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"67528e1bc135ebcfc668f33a_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Stakeholder Map","hash":"stakeholder-map","label":null,"slug":"stakeholder-map","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"67528cddc135ebcfc668f304","name":"Grid Icon Glyph","slug":"grid-icon-glyph","component":"GridIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"66680141f794dd6e0451367a","name":"Organisation","internalName":"Organisation"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"67529040c135ebcfc668f4ae_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"References","hash":"references","label":null,"slug":"references","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"67528cddc135ebcfc668f304","name":"Grid Icon Glyph","slug":"grid-icon-glyph","component":"GridIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"6752902fc135ebcfc668f4a4","name":"Article","internalName":"FeedEntry"},{"id":"67529039c135ebcfc668f4aa","name":"Citation","internalName":"Citation"},{"id":"67528de9c135ebcfc668f328","name":"Catalyst","internalName":"catalyst"},{"id":"67528df9c135ebcfc668f32d","name":"Page","internalName":"page"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]}],"entityAppViews":[],"entityOnboardingViews":[{"id":"680c3a4ebc80e4d0f3cfa2ef_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Trend Expertise Step","hash":"trend-expertise-step","label":null,"slug":"trend-expertise-step","count":0,"showCount":null,"icon":null,"childEntityTypes":[],"type":{"id":"680c394fbc80e4d0f3cfa2d8","name":"Onboarding","slug":"onboarding"},"slices":[{"id":"680c39f2bc80e4d0f3cfa2e0_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Trend Expertise Onboarding Grid","slug":"trend-expertise-onboarding-grid","label":null,"updated":"2025-04-26T01:42:10.20","layout":{"id":"680c3993bc80e4d0f3cfa2dd","name":"Slice Onboarding Trend Expertise Grid","slug":"slice-onboarding-trend-expertise-grid","component":"SliceLayoutOnboardingTrendExpertiseGrid"},"connectedEntities":[],"headerFontType":null,"pretitle":null,"pretitleRich":{"id":"680c39f2bc80e4d0f3cfa2e0_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_pretitleRich","text":""},"title":null,"titleRich":{"id":"680c39f2bc80e4d0f3cfa2e0_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_titleRich","text":"Are you **an industry expert** in any of these Value Chain Themes?"}}]},{"id":"680c3a85bc80e4d0f3cfa2fa_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Profile Types Step","hash":"profile-types-step","label":null,"slug":"profile-types-step","count":0,"showCount":null,"icon":null,"childEntityTypes":[],"type":{"id":"680c394fbc80e4d0f3cfa2d8","name":"Onboarding","slug":"onboarding"},"slices":[{"id":"680c3a82bc80e4d0f3cfa2f7_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Profile Types Onboarding Grid","slug":"profile-types-onboarding-grid","label":null,"updated":"2025-04-26T01:44:34.63","layout":{"id":"680c3a13bc80e4d0f3cfa2e4","name":"Slice Onboarding Profile Types Grid","slug":"slice-onboarding-profile-types-grid","component":"SliceLayoutOnboardingProfileTypesGrid"},"connectedEntities":[],"headerFontType":null,"pretitle":null,"pretitleRich":{"id":"680c3a82bc80e4d0f3cfa2f7_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_pretitleRich","text":""},"title":"Which best describes you?","titleRich":{"id":"680c3a82bc80e4d0f3cfa2f7_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_titleRich","text":""}}]},{"id":"680c3aaabc80e4d0f3cfa2ff_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Objectives Step","hash":"objectives-step","label":null,"slug":"objectives-step","count":0,"showCount":null,"icon":null,"childEntityTypes":[],"type":{"id":"680c394fbc80e4d0f3cfa2d8","name":"Onboarding","slug":"onboarding"},"slices":[{"id":"680c3aa8bc80e4d0f3cfa2fc_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Objectives Onboarding Grid","slug":"objectives-onboarding-grid","label":null,"updated":"2025-04-26T01:45:12.76","layout":{"id":"680c3a3fbc80e4d0f3cfa2ea","name":"Slice Onboarding Objectives Grid","slug":"slice-onboarding-objectives-grid","component":"SliceLayoutOnboardingObjectivesGrid"},"connectedEntities":[],"headerFontType":null,"pretitle":null,"pretitleRich":{"id":"680c3aa8bc80e4d0f3cfa2fc_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_pretitleRich","text":""},"title":"What are your priority objectives?","titleRich":{"id":"680c3aa8bc80e4d0f3cfa2fc_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_titleRich","text":""}}]}],"gptLanguages":[{"id":"65d2eda5ebf7bb9388ffaf1f","name":"English","slug":"english","iso":"en","locale":"en_US","path":"/en","label":"English","menuLabel":null},{"id":"666f70b6e051ad9ef086d1be","name":"Arabic","slug":"arabic","iso":"ar","locale":"ar_AE","path":"/ar","label":"عربي","menuLabel":null},{"id":"666f7161e051ad9ef086d1c4","name":"Spanish","slug":"spanish","iso":"es","locale":"es_ES","path":"/es","label":"español","menuLabel":null},{"id":"666f71c9e051ad9ef086d1c8","name":"German","slug":"german","iso":"de","locale":"de_DE","path":"/de","label":"Deutsch","menuLabel":null},{"id":"65d2eda5ebf7bb9388ffaf20","name":"French","slug":"french","iso":"fr","locale":"fr_FR","path":"/fr","label":"Français","menuLabel":null}],"gptQuestionTemplate":{"id":"662c7f6e81ef1920e3638518","name":"Standard Open Question","slug":"standard-open-question","path":"/prompt-templates/standard-open-question","__typename":"PromptTemplate","_entityTypeName":null,"label":"CopperAI","type":{"id":"662c7f1981ef1920e363850f","name":"Ask","slug":"ask"},"description":{"text":"This template is tailored for providing accurate responses based on specific context. It integrates contextual details from \"contextual information\" and addresses the \"target question\". The response is always in English, prioritizing clarity. If the answer is unknown, the template openly acknowledges this, ensuring honesty and avoiding speculation. This format is ideal for precise, context-sensitive, and truthful answering."},"summary":{"text":"Ask a general question about Website content"},"gptModel":{"id":"67564c4f2f6749787d0e03dc","name":"OpenAI GPT 4o","slug":"open-ai-gpt-4-o","dataSetId":"openai:gpt-4o"},"variablesPrompt":{"text":""},"submitLabel":"Ask","languages":[],"icon":{"id":"67528b9cc135ebcfc668f1a3","name":"AI Lower Case Icon Glyph","slug":"ai-lower-case-icon-glyph","component":"AiLowerCaseIconGlyph"},"variables":[{"id":"6668076bf794dd6e045138d9","name":"question","slug":"question","useVectorStore":true,"label":"What would you like to know?","labelAnother":null,"help":{"text":""},"options":{"text":""},"defaultValue":null,"entityTypes":[],"controlType":{"id":"6667ff19f794dd6e04513656","name":"Textarea","slug":"textarea"},"labelContextual":null,"labelAnotherContextual":null,"helpContextual":{"text":""},"optionsContextual":{"text":""},"defaultValueContextual":null,"entityTypesContextual":[],"controlTypeContextual":{"id":"6667ff19f794dd6e04513656","name":"Textarea","slug":"textarea"}}]},"advertisements":[],"logoVerticalOffset":null,"logoHorizontalOffset":null,"logoVerticalOffsetMobile":null,"logoHorizontalOffsetMobile":null,"logoVerticalOffsetTablet":null,"logoHorizontalOffsetTablet":null,"logoVerticalOffsetDesktop":null,"logoHorizontalOffsetDesktop":null,"logoHeightMobile":44,"logoHeightTablet":null,"logoHeightDesktop":null,"headerHeightMobile":null,"headerHeightTablet":null,"headerHeightDesktop":null,"logo":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1738807465/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_logo__CopperOre_Master_Brand_Identity-colour_cd4vgg.webp","type":"image/webp","width":945,"height":266},"logoInverted":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1738807452/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_logoInverted__CopperOre_Master_Brand_Identity-white_chnucx.webp","type":"image/webp","width":945,"height":266},"footerMenu":null,"footerSecondaryMenu":null,"footerContent":{"text":"© {year} ConnectOre. All Rights Reserved\n"},"creator":null,"poweredBy":{"id":"65d2edadebf7bb9388ffafc8","name":"Shapeable","slug":"shapeable","url":"https://shapeable.ai","logo":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1674010034/platform/organisation/shapeable_logo__shapeable.png","type":"image/png","width":1174,"height":368},"logoInverted":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1729474494/copper-connect/organisation/shapeable_logoInverted__shapeable-logo-inverted_sdcfpk.png","type":"image/png","width":392,"height":118},"logoSubtle":null},"poweredByLabel":null,"poweredByContent":{"text":""},"explorerPage":{"name":"Explorer","title":null,"slug":"explorer","path":"/explorer"},"termsPage":{"name":"Terms of Use","title":null,"slug":"terms-of-use","path":"/terms-of-use"},"homePage":null,"knowledgeHubPage":{"name":"News","title":null,"slug":"news","path":"/news"},"privacyPolicyPage":{"name":"Privacy Policy","title":null,"slug":"privacy-policy","path":"/privacy-policy"},"summary":{"text":"A platform to accelerate industry-wide innovation through collective intelligence and collaborative action"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1713942350/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_thumbnail__site-thumb_bmicl8.png"},"openGraph":{"title":"ConnectOre","date":"2026-07-31T04:44:47.80","description":{"plain":"A platform to accelerate industry-wide innovation through collective intelligence and collaborative action\n"},"image":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1713942350/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_thumbnail__site-thumb_bmicl8.png","type":"image/png","thumbnails":{"full":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1713942350/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_thumbnail__site-thumb_bmicl8.png"}}}},"termsAndConditions":{"text":""},"privacyPolicy":{"text":"At ConnectOre we respect your privacy. We want to ensure that you get the information, content, and experiences that matter most to you. ConnectOre is committed to protecting the privacy of its stakeholders, communities, and other contacts.\n\n## Scope\n\nThis privacy policy applies to all personal data processed by full-time and part-time employees, volunteers when acting on behalf of ConnectOre contractors and partners doing business on behalf of ConnectOre, as well as all legal entities, all operating locations in all countries, and all business processes conducted by ConnectOre.\n\n## Information Collected\n\n#### What information do we collect?\n\nConnectOre collects the following personal data in line with the use purposes explained in a subsequent section:\n\n  * Your name and contact details\n  * Online profile data/usage\n  * Contact information\n  * Social media profile information\n  * Education and professional information\n  * Registration and participation in ConnectOre events and activities \n  * Information about service usage\n  * Cookies\n  * Authentication data\n  * Location information\n  * Author and peer review information\n  * Other information you upload or provide to us\n\n#### How do we use your information?\n\nConnectOre uses (and, where specified, shares) your personal information for the following purposes:\n\n  * To provide support or other services. ConnectOre may use your personal information to provide you with support or other services that you have ordered or requested. ConnectOre may also use your personal information to respond directly to your requests for information, including registrations for webinars, or other specific requests, or pass your contact information to the appropriate ConnectOre supplier or reseller for further follow-up related to your interests.\n  * To provide information based on your needs and respond to your requests. ConnectOre may use your personal information to provide you with notices of new product releases and service developments.\n  * To administer products. ConnectOre may contact you if you make use of (digital) products we offer, to confirm certain information (for example, that you did not experience problems in a download process). We may also use this information to confirm compliance with licensing and other terms of use and may share it with your company/institution.\n  * To assist in your participation in ConnectOre activities. ConnectOre will communicate with you, if you are participating in certain ConnectOre activities such as ConnectOre Summit, authoring or reviewing a ConnectOre article, or ConnectOre humanitarian activities. ConnectOre may send you information such as update messages related to those activities (such as but not limited to the event's content, and event logistics)\n  * To update you on relevant ConnectOre events and opportunities. ConnectOre may communicate with you regarding relevant ConnectOre events and opportunities.\n  * To protect ConnectOre content and services. We may use your information to prevent potentially illegal activities and to enforce our terms and conditions.\n  * To get feedback or input from you. In order to deliver products and services of most interest to our stakeholders, from time to time, we may ask you to provide us input and feedback (for example through surveys).\n\n#### How can you control your information?\n\nYou can control the information we have about you and how we use as follows:\n\n  * If you are a registered guest for ConnectOre Annual Summit 2021, any request for review, revise or correction of your personal data can be sent to john.fennell@copper.com.au specifying your request.\n\n#### Personal data about minors and children\n\nConnectOre does not knowingly collect data from or about children under 16 without the permission of parent(s)/guardian(s). If we learn that we have collected personal information from a child under 16, we will delete that information as quickly as possible. If you believe that we might have any information from or about a child under age 16, please contact us.\n\n#### How will you know if the Privacy Policy is changed?\n\nConnectOre may update its Privacy Policy from time to time. If we make any material changes you will be notified by means of a notice on our website prior on the date the change becomes effective. We encourage you to periodically review this page for the latest information on our privacy practices.\n\n## Technical And Regulatory Information\n\n#### Logging practices\n\nConnectOre automatically records the Internet Protocol (IP) addresses of visitors. The IP address is a unique number assigned to every computer on the internet. Generally, an IP address changes each time you connect to the internet (it is a \"dynamic\" address). Note, however, that if you have a broadband connection, depending on your individual circumstance, the IP address that we collect may contain information that could be deemed identifiable. This is because, with some broadband connections, your IP address doesn't change (it is \"static\") and could be associated with your personal computer.\n\nAs well as recording the IP addresses of users, ConnectOre may also keep track of sites that users visited immediately prior to visiting ConnectOre's website and the search terms they used to find it. We keep track of the pages visited on ConnectOre's website, the amount of time spent on those pages and the types of searches done on them. Your searches remain confidential and anonymous. ConnectOre uses this information only for statistical purposes to find out which pages users find most useful and to improve the website.\nConnectOre also captures and stores information that you transmit. This may include:\n\n  * Browser/Device type/version\n  * Operating system used\n  * Media Access Control (MAC) address\n  * Date and time of the server request\n  * Volume of data transferred\n\n#### External links behaviour\n\nSome of the links on ConnectOre's websites link to other sites created and maintained by other public- and/or private-sector organizations. ConnectOre provides these links solely for your information and convenience. When you transfer to an outside website, you are leaving ConnectOre domain, and ConnectOre's information management policies no longer apply. ConnectOre encourages you to read the privacy statement of each external website that you visit before you provide any personal data.\n\n#### Cookies and web beacons\n\nCookies and web beacons are electronic placeholders that are placed on your device by websites to track your individual movements on that website over time. ConnectOre uses both session-based cookies (which last only for the duration of the user's session) and persistent cookies (which remain on your device and provide information about the session you are in and waits for the next time you use that site again).\n\nThese cookies and web beacons provide useful information to ConnectOre, enabling us to recognize repeat users, facilitate the user's access to and use of our sites, allows us to track usage behavior, and to balance the usage of our websites on all ConnectOre web servers.\nTracking cookies, third-party cookies, and other technologies such as web beacons may be used to process additional information, enable non-core functionalities on ConnectOre website and enable third-party functions (such as a social media \"share\" link). We may also include web beacons and other similar technology in promotional email messages to determine whether the messages have been opened.\n\n#### Do Not Track (DNT)\n\nThe online advertising industry has self-regulatory initiatives designed to provide consumers a choice in the types of ads they may see online and to conveniently opt-out from online behavioral ads served by some or all of the companies participating in these programs. Our websites do not respond to DNT consumer browser settings.\n\n#### Responses to legal requests\n\nConnectOre reserves the right to share your information to respond to duly authorized information requests of governmental authorities or where required by law.\n\n#### Your data rights\n\nConnectOre complies with all applicable data privacy laws and regulations including, but not limited to, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). Under these laws and regulations, you may have certain rights to your data. Should you wish to exercise any of these rights, please send an email request to john.fennell@copper.com.au with \"Data Privacy Request'' in the subject line and in the email please identify the specific privacy right you request assistance with. Please note additional information may be requested prior to fulfilling a request and that ConnectOre reserves the right to charge a fee, where permitted, to cover the cost of certain requests.\n\n#### How do I contact you if there is an issue?\nIf you have any questions or concerns about this Privacy Policy or about the use of your personal information, please feel free to contact us by email at john.fennell@copper.com.au"},"welcomeUrl":"https://connectore.org/app/welcome","welcomeTitle":"Welcome to ConnectOre and thanks for joining us! ","invitationAction":"join the ConnectOre community","setupCompletionMessage":null,"languages":[],"brandColors":[],"showLogin":true,"showShareMenu":null,"showFollowMenu":true,"showPlatformLogin":null,"showContactUs":null,"loginLabel":"Explorer Login","platformLoginLabel":"Community Platform","headerButtons":[]},"includeProfile":true,"disableProfileEditing":false,"dynamicEntityTypeNames":["Person","Organisation"],"profilePath":"/app/profile","welcomePath":"/app/welcome","id":"67635df3cc7194b0ec39497b","slug":"practical-example-of-bulk-sorting-trial-1","entityPath":"/sub-topics/practical-example-of-bulk-sorting-trial-1","openGraph":{},"entityTypeName":"SubTopic","name":"Practical Example of Bulk Sorting Trial","updated":"2024-12-20T01:07:39.95","__type":"SubTopic"}},
    "staticQueryHashes": ["1044227382","1158597448","1242646999","1427075558","1452322194","1520036161","1545705019","1586309863","1606754935","1816168740","1864381666","1903214493","1945056504","1989845544","2034981229","2181044613","2409034939","2463401854","2526615987","2642656775","2862279633","2867243664","2910164142","2912920178","296816903","3073584486","3150399266","3172506128","3320076387","3447680494","3453148481","3624873332","364221563","3692255024","3778988535","3782604890","4091857177","4216505212","591477963","701411134","758936535","80004486","857137463","881103158"]}