{
    "componentChunkName": "component---src-gatsby-entities-sub-topic-tsx",
    "path": "/sub-topics/ge-in-ies-methodology",
    "result": {"data":{"platform":{"subTopic":{"__typename":"Platform_SubTopic","_schema":{"label":"Sub Topic","pluralLabel":"Sub Topics"},"openGraph":{"title":"GE in IES Methodology","description":{"text":"Overview[](#Overview)\n=====================\n\nThis page describes the methodology developed by CRC ORE during  development of an operation [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design..."},"image":null},"id":"65d2edd7ebf7bb9388ffb16a","slug":"ge-in-ies-methodology","name":"GE in IES Methodology","path":"/sub-topics/ge-in-ies-methodology","outlineNumber":"2.4.2","color":{"__typename":"Platform_Color","id":"65d2ed7febf7bb9388ffab3a","slug":"core-12","name":"Core 12","value":"#3b6673","darkValue":"#2b4b56","veryDarkValue":"#1c3239"},"intro":{"id":"65d2edd7ebf7bb9388ffb16a_intro","text":"Overview[](#Overview)\n=====================\n\nThis page describes the methodology developed by CRC ORE during  development of an operation [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) for a copper mine in South America."},"description":{"id":"65d2edd7ebf7bb9388ffb16a_description","text":"The [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> then was used for technical evaluation of several scenarios including [Grade Engineering](/pages/wikiore-introduction-to-grade-engineering) (GE) and <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b>.\n\nThe project was the first of its type to demonstrate the [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) capabilities to evaluate entire operation [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) performance for a range of <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> and <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> scenarios utilising <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> across the deposit. Hence this project was selected to establish a guideline for the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> technical [opportunity assessment](/sub-topics/opportunity-assessments).\n\n<b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> is a process integration approach to maximise productivity by evaluating the impact of blast intensity and <b title=\"General term for broken rock (e.g. muckpile, crusher product etc..).\">rock fragmentation</b> on overall <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> performance. <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> is an integrated approach to early rejection of non-valuable material, leading to ore upgrades and reductions in processing costs per metal produced. <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> is applied to ores with proven [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) (ND) of valuables to specific <b title=\"Classified material based on specific size constraints (i.e. two specific sizes).\">size fraction</b>s, and to ores where this deportment can be further promoted through [differential blasting](/pages/wikiore-induced-deportment)ing (DB) techniques. The <b title=\"Materials response to a given preconcentration technology.\">amenability</b> of an ore to <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> is determined by the ore-specific [Response Ranking](/sub-topics/natural-deportment-characterisation) (RR) parameter derived from the relationship between the cumulative <b title=\"Relative proportion of feed mass in the accept stream after preconcentration.\">mass pull</b> fractions of an ore sorting screen and the resulting ore upgrades.\n\nGE scenarios are simulated in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) for a range of blast intensities and pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s, whereas <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> scenarios are simulated for a range of blast intensities and target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b>s. Every single<b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> or <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> scenario results on a <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> level, ore upgrade and subsequent [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) recovery for every single <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> in the resource [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model). These<b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> and <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> scenarios were originally mass simulated on a <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> by <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> basis, which demanded significant computing resources and time. Therefore, an alternative approach was then developed to reduce the required time and cost in the process by simulating selected ores representing a small portion of the blocks in the <b title=\"Digitised model of the deposit.\">resource model</b> . Then the simulation results fed a machine-learning algorithm which will produce performance predictions to populate the rest of the blocks in the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model). The selected ores correspond to those specific blocks in the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model) with all possible combinations of the key attributes.   The key attributes used in the blocks selection process were <b title=\"Materials response to a given preconcentration technology.\">amenability</b> to pre-concentration (RR), and hardness parameters (<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> and Bond BMWI).\n\nThe development of site-specific integrated mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b>s in IES, to be used as a <b title=\"Selected benchmark for comparison to.\">base case</b> condition for the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> and <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> simulations, requires either survey-based <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b>s or cleaned historical process information of the production units in the [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain). The integrated [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> then is fine-tuned with [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) historical performance, to bring the <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> simulations as closely as possible to the [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) performance considering the process constraints and maximum capacity of all production units involved.\n\nIntroduction[](#Introduction)\n=============================\n\nModelling and simulation have been used for the optimisation of minerals processing plants over the past 40 years, from the first [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) models developed by the [JKMRC](https://smi.uq.edu.au/JKMRC) in the early 70’s to those models for the other processes of the mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain), i.e. <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> and [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation), continuously developed and improved over the past 20 years. However, simulating the impact of one process on the next downstream process, with the purpose of integrating processes, has tr[adit](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adit)ionally been limited to use separate stand-alone software platforms.\n\nThe Integrated Extraction Simulator (IES), the next generation of cloud-based, powerful, reliable and accurate simulation of the entire an operation [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain), has been developed from the combined research of the Cooperative Research Centre for Optimising Ore Extraction (CRC ORE) and research associates ([JKMRC](https://smi.uq.edu.au/JKMRC), [amira](https://amira.global/)).\n\nIES is a cloud-based simulation and optimisation platform designed to represent mine operation [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)s performance which integrates [drilling & blasting](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drilling_and_blasting), [crushing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher), [grinding](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29), [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation), and other down the stream process and material handling units in a single platform. This provides mine managers with a cloud-based decision support platform that enables production units to coordinate and optimise system value across all operational metrics. This includes the [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) capabilities to handle multi-variable simulations across the mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) including [Grade Engineering](/pages/wikiore-introduction-to-grade-engineering) (GE) and <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b>. <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> is an integrated approach developed by CRC ORE to early rejection of non-valuable material through pre-concentration techniques, leading to ore upgrades and reductions in processing costs. [GE simulations](/sub-topics/strategy-evaluation) can be conducted on ores with proven [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) (ND) of valuables to specific <b title=\"Classified material based on specific size constraints (i.e. two specific sizes).\">size fraction</b>s, and on those where this deportment can be further promoted through [differential blasting](/pages/wikiore-induced-deportment)ing (DB) techniques. The <b title=\"Materials response to a given preconcentration technology.\">amenability</b> of an ore to <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> is determined by the ore-specific [Response Ranking](/sub-topics/natural-deportment-characterisation) (RR) parameter derived from the relationship between the cumulative <b title=\"Relative proportion of feed mass in the accept stream after preconcentration.\">mass pull</b> fractions and the resulting ore upgrades. <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> is a process integration approach to maximise productivity by evaluating the impact of <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> on overall performance including <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> .\n\nMethodology[](#Methodology)\n===========================\n\nThe methodology followed by CRC ORE, during the development of a mine[value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> and subsequent simulation study, is summarized as follows:\n\n1.  Data analysis.\n    *   Collate and clean relevant historical processing data available for each of the processes.\n    *   Split this historical processing data into 2 periods. Period 1 to be used for the fine tuning of the mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> . Period 2 to be used for the validation of the mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b>s.\n    *   Identify [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) constrains.\n2.  mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> development.\n    *   Development of <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b>s for each production unit separately.\n3.  Set up the site-specific <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies)\n    *   Draw the <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> .\n    *   Transfer all the individual process models to IES.\n    *   Define a preliminary mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> .\n    *   Fine tune the preliminary mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> .\n        *   Use the preliminary mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) to simulate the <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> with corresponding blast designs as per Period 1. If the error between model predicted <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> and <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b>s and historical data for this period is in an acceptable range, then move to the validation step. If the predictions do not compare well with real performance of Period 1, then fine tune by adjusting key individual equipment model ([SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) model for <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> and [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) model for <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> ) so the entire mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> matches historical processing performance reasonably well. Some wrappers around the semi-empirical process models might need to be developed and incorporated to these models for more accurate predictions.\n    *   Validate the integrated mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> .\n        *   Use the fine-tuned mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> to simulate the <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> with corresponding blast designs for Period 2. If the predicted <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> and <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b>s match historical data for this period reasonably well, then the mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> is validated and becomes the <b title=\"Selected benchmark for comparison to.\">base case</b> <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> . Go to simulations. If the predictions do not compare well with real performance of Period 2, go back to model fine tuning step. Most likely more historical data are required to cover all possible conditions occurs in the process.\n4.  Define the type of simulations and their scenarios.\n    *   Type of simulations can be <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> and/or <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> .\n    *   Adapt the <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> to be used for the given simulations.\n    *   Define the scenarios for each type of simulation, i.e. the combinations of:\n        *   Blast intensities and pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s, for [GE simulations](/sub-topics/strategy-evaluation).\n        *   Blast intensities and target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> , for <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> simulations\n5.  Select the blocks for each scenario. This can be either:\n    *   Every single <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> in the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model), provided that every single <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> in the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model) has all key attributes including grade, RR and hardness parameters; or\n    *   Selected blocks only. Specific blocks in the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model) with all possible combinations of the key attributes. In this case a methodology like [machine learning](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_learning) techniques is required to use the selected <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> simulation results and distribute it in the entire [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model).\n6.  Run the simulations\n    *   Set up the in-line Optimizer in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) for each type of simulation, to account for the action taken by plant operators to maintain product specifications when dealing with different <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> . \n7.  Conduct a sanity check on all simulation results.\n8.  Populate the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model) with the [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) predicted ranges for achievable <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b>s, ore upgrades and [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) recoveries, for every single <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> in the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model). This can be imported from either:\n    *   The [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies)  <b title=\"IES specific term for repeated simulations of a circuit.\">mass simulation</b> results directly, if the simulations were conducted on a <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> by <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> basis, or\n    *   The predictions of a machine-learning algorithm trained with the results of the [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) simulations on the selected ores.\n9.  Report\n\n [![IES ImplementationFlowchart](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316129/wikiore/71.jpg)](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316129/wikiore/71.jpg) \n\nData Requirements[](#Data_Requirements)\n=======================================\n\nThe data required for the implementation of an integrated model in[IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) can be classified in three large groups as follows:\n\n*   <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> – as input for the simulations.\n*   Survey data – as the basis for the model development.\n*   Historical data – for production unit model development, fine tuning and validation.\n\nMore details are provided as follows.\n\n<b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b>[](#ore_characteristics)\n-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nThe following measured ore-specific properties are required for the various stages of the[IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) Implementation process:\n\n*   <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> :\n    *   UCS and Point Load.\n*   [Grade Engineering](/pages/wikiore-introduction-to-grade-engineering):\n    *   [Response Ranking](/sub-topics/natural-deportment-characterisation) (RR) for the key commodities.\n*   [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution):\n    *   Pairs of <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> (from<b title=\"Drop weight test\">DWT</b> or SMC) and Bond [BMWI](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Chester_Bond#Bond_Work_Index) measured on the same samples, and on as many samples as possible to understand <b title=\"Parameters that define resistance to different comminution types.\">ore hardness</b> variability across the deposit.\n    *   Any available ore characteristic measured, ideally from any [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill)ing test, paired with measured <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> for the development of site-specific proxies.\n    *   Ore SG.\n\nSurvey Data[](#Survey_Data)\n---------------------------\n\nThis is the data collected with a survey with the purpose of developing steady-state models for a baseline condition in IES.\n\nIf a [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> has already been developed, made available and accepted as a true representation of the real <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> , then the survey data is no longer necessary. If the survey-based [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> is to be developed, then the following data is required.\n\nThe following survey data sets must correspond to the same ore campaign and time window.\n\n### <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b>[](#ore_characteristics_2)\n\nThe following ore-specific properties are required to develop <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> and [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> s:\n\n*   Rock mass characteristics\n    *   UCS\n    *   Point Load\n*   [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution)\n    *   Drop Weight Test results\n        *   A, b and ta.\n        *   Appearance Function\n        *   Energy vs [Size-Reduction](Size-Reduction) relationship\n    *   Bond [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) Work Index\n\nThe<b title=\"Drop weight test\">DWT</b> measures the ore-specific resistance to impact breakage, being impact the main breakage mechanism going on in [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill)s and crushers, whereas the standard Bond test measures the ore-specific grindability that is needed to achieve the target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> in [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)s. These [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> can either be measured or approximated using site-specific proxies developed for this purpose.\n\n### <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b>[](#blast_fragmentation)\n\nThe following is the type of information collected during a blast audit that is required to develop a site-specific <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> model, in addition to the rock mass characteristics as stated in Section 3.2.1:\n\n*   Structural parameters\n    *   RQD\n    *   Fracture Frequency or <b title=\"Fracture patterns inherent to a rock mass.\">In-situ block size</b> .\n*   Blast design:\n    *   burden, spacing, timing, powder factor, <b title=\"Individual levels within an open pit.\">bench</b> height, charge length, drill hole diameter, <b title=\"Gravel used to pack the top of blast holes to confine explosive energy.\">stemming</b> length, explosive type, VOD.\n*   The measured fragmentation resulting from each blast design including:\n    *   Image analysis (Split, Visio Rock) on the <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> material\n    *   Belt-cuts on the [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) product\n\nThe image analysis technologies have an inherent limitation to measure fragmentations as cameras do not get to see the fine material of the distribution, often sitting underneath the large rocks on the belt or on the stockpile or due to limitation in the delineation algorithms. Therefore, in order to determine the<b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> size distribution, it is necessary to check if the camera reading is calibrated or develop a calibration strategy to correct the camera reading with available [belt cut](/sub-topics/sampling) surveys.\n\n### Crushers[](#Crushers)\n\nThe following set of data, recorded for the same time window, is required to develop a crusher model using the Andersen/Whiten model:\n\n*   Stream data\n    *   Measured <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate (tph) and [particle size](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Particle_size) distribution (PSD)\n    *   Measured crusher product PSD\n*   <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b>\n    *   Appearance Function\n    *   Energy vs Size-Reduction relationship\n*   Operating data\n    *   Closed Side Setting (mm)\n    *   Power draw (kW)\n    *   No-load power (kW)\n*   Model Fitted Parameters\n    *   Regression coefficients\n\nThis applies to both [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) and [pebble crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher). The <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> to the [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher), given by the ROM, can be either measured or model predicted. The <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> stream data usually referred to as <b title=\"Post blast material in the load/haul cycle.\">run of mine</b> (ROM) is required in all cases.\n\n### [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill)[](#SAG_mill)\n\nThe following data set, recorded for the same time window, is required to develop the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) model using the Variable Rates (VR) model.\n\n*   Stream data:\n    *   Measured <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate (tph) and <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> PSD\n    *   <b title=\"Material accounting and adjusting within a system based on sampled points.\">mass balance</b>d discharge size distribution and % Solids\n*   Dimensions:\n    *   Internal Diameter (m)\n    *   Internal Length (m)\n    *   <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> trunnion diameter (m)\n    *   <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> and Discharge end Cone Angles (°)\n    *   Grate/Pebble Port sizes (mm)\n    *   Pebble Port Fraction of Total Open Area\n    *   Grate open area fraction\n    *   Mean relative radial position of grate aperture\n*   <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b>\n    *   <b title=\"Selected benchmark for comparison to.\">base case</b> (survey) Total Load (%)\n    *   Ball Load (%)\n    *   Ball Top Size (mm)\n    *   Fraction of <b title=\"Speed at which centrifugal forces equal gravitational forces at the mill shell's inside surface and no balls fall from its position.\">critical speed</b> (%)\n    *   Power Draw (kW)\n*   <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b>\n    *   A\n    *   b\n    *   ta\n*   Model Fitted Parameters\n    *   Breakage Constant 1\n    *   Breakage Constant 2\n    *   Breakage Constant 3\n    *   Breakage Constant 4\n    *   Breakage Constant 5\n    *   Grate/Pebble Port size (mm)\n    *   Fine Size (mm)\n\n### [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) [trommel](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trommel_screen)/Screen[](#SAG_mill_trommel_Screen)\n\nThe following set of data, recorded for the same time window, is required to develop the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) [trommel](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trommel_screen)/Screen model using the Simple Efficiency Curve model:\n\n*   Stream data:\n    *   <b title=\"Material accounting and adjusting within a system based on sampled points.\">mass balance</b>d <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate (tph), <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> <b title=\"Particle Size Distribution\">PSD</b> and % Solids\n    *   <b title=\"Material accounting and adjusting within a system based on sampled points.\">mass balance</b>d flowrate (tph), size distribution, water additions and % Solids in the product streams\n*   Model Fitted Parameters:\n    *   D 50 size (mm)\n    *   Water Split to Underflow (%)\n    *   Alpha - Sharpness of Efficiency Curve\n\n### [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)[](#ball_mill)\n\nThe following set of data, recorded for the same time window, is required to develop the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) model using the Perfect Mixing model:\n\n*   Stream data:\n    *   <b title=\"Material accounting and adjusting within a system based on sampled points.\">mass balance</b>d <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate (tph), and <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> PSD.\n    *   <b title=\"Material accounting and adjusting within a system based on sampled points.\">mass balance</b>d discharge<b title=\"Particle Size Distribution\">PSD</b> and % Solids\n*   Dimensions:\n    *   Original and Simulated Mill Internal Diameters (m)\n    *   Simulated Internal Length (m)\n    *   <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> and Discharge end Cone Angles (°)\n*   <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> :\n    *   Original and Simulated Mill Ball Load (%)\n    *   Original and Simulated Mill Ball Top Size (mm)\n    *   Original and Simulated Mill Fraction of <b title=\"Speed at which centrifugal forces equal gravitational forces at the mill shell's inside surface and no balls fall from its position.\">critical speed</b> (%)\n*   <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> :\n    *   Original and Simulated Mill Bond [BMWI](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Chester_Bond#Bond_Work_Index) (<b title=\"KiloWattHours per tonne\">kWh/t</b> )\n*   Model Fitted Parameters:\n    *   Size 1 and Ln (R/D) 1 \\*\n    *   Size 2 and Ln (R/D) 2 \\*\n    *   Size 3 and Ln (R/D) 3 \\*\n    *   Size 4 and Ln (R/D) 4 \\*\n\n### Hydro[cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone)[](#Hydrocyclone)\n\nThe following set of data, recorded for the same time window, is required to develop the hydro[cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) model using the Nageswararao model:\n\nStream data:\n\n*   *   <b title=\"Material accounting and adjusting within a system based on sampled points.\">mass balance</b>d <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate (tph) and <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> size distribution\n    *   <b title=\"Material accounting and adjusting within a system based on sampled points.\">mass balance</b>d <b title=\"Particle Size Distribution\">PSD</b> and % Solids\n*   Dimensions:\n    *   [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) Diameter\n    *   Inlet Diameter\n    *   Vortex Finder Diameter\n    *   Spigot Diameter\n    *   Cylinder Length\n    *   Cone Angle\n*   <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> :\n    *   Water Split to Overflow (%)\n    *   [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) Pressure (kPa)\n*   Model Fitted Parameters:\n    *   KD – D50 constant\n    *   KQ – Capacity constant\n    *   Kv 1 – Volume Split constant\n    *   Kw 1 – Weight Split constant\n    *   Alpha - Sharpness of Efficiency Curve\n\nHistorical Data[](#Historical_Data)\n-----------------------------------\n\nHistorical blasting data including <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> data and impolemented designs.\n\nHistorical process data, the following is the key process data required for model development and validation.\n\n| **Area**             | **Equipment**                           | **Metric**                         |\n|:----------------:|:-----------------------------------:|:-------------------------------:|\n| [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution)   | Primary/ [pebble crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher)    | Power draw (kW)                 |\n|                  |                                    | CSS (mm)                        |\n|                  | SAG <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> Conveyor   | Image analysis readings         |\n|                  |                                    | <b title=\"Device used to weigh material on a conveyor belt.\">Weightometer</b> readings (tph)  |\n|                  | [pebble crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) Product Conveyor  | <b title=\"Device used to weigh material on a conveyor belt.\">Weightometer</b> readings   |\n|                  | [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill)   | Power draw (kW)                 |\n|                  |                                    | Bearing pressure               |\n|                  |                                    | Weight (t)                     |\n|                  |                                    | Ball Load (%)                  |\n|                  |                                    | Mill speed (rpm)               |\n|                  |                                    | Density (%Sol)                 |\n|                  | [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) | Power draw (kW)                 |\n|                  |                                    | Mill speed (rpm)               |\n|                  |                                    | Density (%Sol)                 |\n|                  | [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone)s  | Number of units in parallel    |\n|                  |                                    | Operating pressure (kPa)       |\n|                  |                                    | <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> density (%Sol)  |\n|                  |                                    | <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> volumetric flowrate (m^3/h) |\n|                  |                                    | Overflow <b title=\"80% passing size in product material.\">p80</b> size (mm)  |\n| [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation)  | Product                            | [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) recovery (%)  |\n|                  |                                    | <b title=\"Product generally produced by metal ore mines.\">concentrate</b> grade (%)  |\n\nOne reading per minute or average every 5 minutes resolution, for six month or a year would normally suffice.\n\nThis data is used for the model validation, as well as for the development of wrappers and calibration methods to be incorporated to the models when required. Wrappers are intended to either address some limitations of the current models as well as to improve the accuracy of the model predictions.\n\n1\\. Mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> Development (Base Case)[](#Mine_value_chain_flowsheet_Development_Base_Case_)\n===================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================\n\nMathematical models for the entire mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain), i.e. blasting, [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) and [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation), are to be developed either in IES, once the functionality is available, or in stand-alone software packages such as [JKSimMet](https://jktech.com.au/products/software) and [JKSimFloat](https://jktech.com.au/products/software). If these survey-based models are developed in stand-alone software packages, then the fitted model parameters, along with the corresponding base line survey data, are to be manually transferred to IES.\n\nSurveys on processing plants are rarely conducted for both [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) and [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) at the same time for the same conditions. The production unit models are usually developed separately, so a set of cleaned, cross-referenced historical data collected from all production units in the entire [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) (e.g. blasting, [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) and [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation)) is required to integrate the processes in a single platform like IES, and predict the entire mine[value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) performance seamlessly. In addition to this, <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> back from site metallurgists is key going forward.\n\nIt is expected that the number of <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> values available to be limited. Therefore, some proxies are needed to be developed based on any other available attribute, ideally from a [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill)ing test, paired with measured <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> values.\n\nBlast Fragmentation Model[](#Blast_Fragmentation_Model)\n-------------------------------------------------------\n\nThe following steps were followed to develop a <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> model:\n\n1.  Set up the generic Kuz Ram with Crushed Zone (KRCZ) <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> model with the rock mass mechanic characteristics and structural parameters available.\n2.  Fine tune the model to match the fine-end of the measured [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher)  <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> distribution available for each of the blast designs.\n\nPrimary Crusher Model[](#Primary_Crusher_Model)\n-----------------------------------------------\n\nThe following was the procedure followed to develop the [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) model:\n\n1.  Three measured [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> distributions with corresponding Image Analysis readings were made available to CRC ORE. These PSDs and Image Analysis readings came from three surveys’ samples that were taken from the [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) product, as part of a routine calibration process of the Image Analysis system.\n2.  The Rosin-Rammler model was fitted to each measured size distribution and each Image Analysis readings. This resulted on each calibration sample having two sets of Rosin-Rammler model fitted parameters (‘Dn’ and ‘N’), one from the measured size distribution and one from the Image Analysis reading.\n3.  Scaling factors were then determined to adjust the Image Analysis readings, so they match the measured size distributions. This was then applied to convert all Image Analysis readings to size distributions. The scaling factors were given by the ratio (‘Dn’ from measured size distribution)/(‘Dn’ from Image Analysis Readings) and (‘N’ from measured PSD)/(‘N’ from Image Analysis Readings). Refer to Appendix 4. The Swebrec model, or any other equivalent model, can also be used as an alternative to Rosin-Rammler, if they approximate the size distributions more accurately.\n4.  The Andersen/Whiten (crusher) model can be developed with all available measured<b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> fragmentation and corresponding measured [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> distributions.\n5.  The [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) model was validated with the [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) product PSDs available for the second half of 2017.\n\nThe following steps are recommended to be explored to complement/improve the procedure:\n\n1.  Check for consistency of the Image Analysis readings in the first place:\n    *   Group the Image Analysis readings in three size ranges only, i.e. ‘<b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> ’ (>4 inches), ‘Upper Intermediate’ (2 to 4 inches), ‘Lower Intermediate’ (3/4 to 2 inches), and ‘<b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> ’ (<3/4 inches), with the ‘<b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> ’ being calculated by difference from 100%. Using 3 size ranges only has the potential to both, reduce the noise of multiple size measurements, and simplify the conversion from Image Analysis readings to size distributions.\n    *   Identify 3 to 4 periods of time, in the process data, where both <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> and SAG power are maintained constant within each time window.\n    *   Plot frequency distributions of all readings (<b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> , Upper Intermediate, Lower Intermediate) within each of these time windows, and see whether medians of each distribution correlate with SAG <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> , i.e. more ‘<b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> ’ should correlate with higher <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b>s, whereas more ‘Intermediate’ should correlate with lower <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b>s, provided that <b title=\"Parameters that define resistance to different comminution types.\">ore hardness</b> remains constant. Allow for the retention time in the stockpile while cross referencing image analysis and <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> readings.\n2.  Model development: Use Master/Slave Model Fitting with the 3 or 4 datasets (identified periods of time) to develop a model for the [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher). The Master/Slave Model Fitting technique, available in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) can be used to develop a single model based on multiple datasets, ideally covering a wide range of <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> , which is meant to be a more robust model. If data and resources are available, a combination of the Master/Slave and the Multi-Stage model calibration approach can be developed. Keep in mind that this preliminary [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) model will be fine-tuned later during the ‘entire <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> ’ <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> fit.\n3.  Validation of the Image Analysis: This validation is not done in real time, i.e. not for each instant measurement, but for the average of specific time windows.\n    *   See how Image Analysis ‘calculated’ size distributions compare with any measured size distribution if available, and how they correlate with SAG <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> . Allow for a retention time in the stockpile, given by the time the image is taken and the time the material gets to the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill).\n    *   Again, identify new periods of time where both <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> & SAG power are constant within each time window. Plot frequency distributions for ‘<b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> ’, ‘Upper Intermediate’, ‘Lower Intermediate’ readings for each time window and see how the medians correlate with <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> .\n4.  Account for the ore-specific resistance to impact breakage (<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> ) in and primary [crushing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) stage. It is expected that the harder ores will produce <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> r [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) products with less <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> from the ROM, and the other way around for the softer ores, i.e. finer [primary crusher](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) products with more <b title=\"Subjective term for the smaller sized component of feed\">fines</b> from the ROM. This consistency can be achieved by correlating the ore-specific resistance to impact breakage (<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> ) to the rock mass mechanical properties (derived from proxies) used in the <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> model.\n\nSAG Mill Model[](#SAG_Mill_Model)\n---------------------------------\n\nThe Variable Rates (VR) model was used as the basis for the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) model development, as part of the integrated <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> model in IES. The <b title=\"Variable Rates Model\">VR model</b> however was incorporated with new capabilities, developed by CRC ORE, to overcome some of the limitations in its form available in [JKSimMet](https://jktech.com.au/products/software) V6.2.\n\nIt is well established that the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) total load changes with <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> , and so do breakage rates to reflect the impact of the new total load condition on mill performance. Despite the <b title=\"Variable Rates Model\">VR model</b> includes an algorithm to roughly approximate the new total load when conditions change, this information is not used internally to adjust breakage rates accordingly. To date this use case has been addressed manually by [JKTECH](https://jktech.com.au/) with the support of an Excel spreadsheet containing formula to calculate the breakage rate constants for the mill under different mill loads. Hence, the <b title=\"Variable Rates Model\">VR model</b> available in [JKSimMet](https://jktech.com.au/products/software) V6.2 is limited to simulate changes in the <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> such as mill speed and ball load, maintaining the same total load as per the base line. Due to this limitation, any individual change in the conditions that is simulated must be followed by a second change, typically in <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> , aimed at bringing the calculated total load back to that at the base line (survey) condition so the breakage rates are applicable again. This second step in the <b title=\"Variable Rates Model\">VR model</b> is done manually, on a trial and error basis.\n\nTo address these limitations, CRC ORE has developed “wrapper” codes around the model to create a custom model. The wrapper code has two components which provide the ability to simulate different mill loads.  The wrapper code now contains the logic in the Excel spreadsheet with the breakage rate constants dynamically updating to be aligned with the calculated mill load. This algorithm was coded into the [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) platform models, the “VR/VL Semi Autogenous Mill” model which uses the total load prediction already built-in the <b title=\"Variable Rates Model\">VR model</b> ; and “VR/Predictive Load Semi Autogenous Mill” model which uses the total load predicted by a more robust machine-learning algorithm linked to <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> and <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> . In both models the breakage rate constants are adjusted automatically for the calculated load. The <b title=\"IES specific term for repeated simulations of a circuit.\">mass simulation</b>s are therefore conducted smoothly.\n\n [![IES VRstucture](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316131/wikiore/68.jpg)](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316131/wikiore/68.jpg) \n\nThe following steps summarise the steps that were followed for the development of the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) model:\n\n1.  Develop proxies for approximating the ore-specific A, b and ta values to use in the simulations. The following steps were followed to develop the proxies for <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> and ta:\n    *   DWi Model as a function of SPI, BWI, Ci, [SG](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relative_density) – polynomial trend.\n    *   <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> Model as a function of [SG](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relative_density) and<b title=\"Drop Weight Index\">Dwi</b> Model\n    *   b Model as a function of <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> Model.\n    *   A Model=IF(<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> Model/b Model)<100,(<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> Model/b Model), 100\\]\n    *   ta Model as a function of <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> Model\n    \n\nApproximated hardness values based on proxies are to be taken with caution, as there is an inherent loss in accuracy that in some cases it is likely to be significant.\n\n1.  Develop a wrapper to predict the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) total load, for which the following variables were identified as key drivers:\n    *   Ore properties (SPI, BWI, Ci),\n    *   <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> size (% passing 4 inches in <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> )\n    *   <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> (%Solids, <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> , % [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill)  <b title=\"Speed at which centrifugal forces equal gravitational forces at the mill shell's inside surface and no balls fall from its position.\">critical speed</b> , ball load).\n    \n\nRelevant historical process data for these variables, including the resulting estimated total loads for specific time windows, were made available to CRC ORE. This information was used with a [machine learning](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_learning) algorithm and an Artificial Neural Network (ANN) approach to develop a model that can predict total load\n\n1.  The wrapper that predicts total load is complemented with the equations available in Excel, developed by [JKMRC](https://smi.uq.edu.au/JKMRC), to adjust the breakage rates for the new total load. The wrapper was then coded into the existing <b title=\"Variable Rates Model\">VR model</b> within IES.\n2.  A second modification was made to the generic SAG model to improve the accuracy of predictions of mill performance for a wide range of mill speeds. This was done through a multi-state calibration process:\n    *   Four mill speed ranges (in %Cs) were determined for the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) at this site: <70% - 72.7%>, <72.8% - 73.4%>, <73.5% - 74.4%>, <74.5 – 75%>.\n    *   Identify periods of time in the process historical data where the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) run consistently within each of the mill speed ranges above.\n    *   Tune the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) model breakage rates in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) or [JKSimMet](https://jktech.com.au/products/software) to the relevant data for the clustered data in the first step.\n    *   Once this new capability is coded into the VR/PL model in IES, the model will now select the right set of breakage rates to use for any mill speed simulated.\n\nThe alternative to this process is to run extra mini surveys at different mill conditions (i.e. mill speed) which was not considered at this site, as it requires more resources and time.\n\n[Cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) Model[](#Cyclone_Model)\n-----------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nThe Nageswararao model was used as the basis for the [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) model development at this site. As part of the fine tuning of the entire mine[value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) model, the D 50 equation in the Nageswararao [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) model was replaced with a new equation, developed by CRC ORE, aimed at improving the accuracy of the model predicted final <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> when the Bond [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) Work Index changes in the historical data. The D50 size in the original Nageswararao model is linked to the [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) input/output streams characteristics and [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) operation condition during the survey, whereas in this study, D 50 size was tuned by Bond [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) Work Index to minimise the error in the model prediction.\n\nThe following steps were followed by CRC ORE when developing the [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) model:\n\n1.  Setup the Nageswararao [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) model in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) based on the model developed in other software packages such as [JKSimMet](https://jktech.com.au/products/software) or can be developed in IES <b title=\"Mill Performance Manager\">MPM</b> mode using the equipment dimensions and corresponding survey <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> .\n2.  Once the entire mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain)  <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> is setup, run simulations for a wide range of Bond [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) Work Indices and see how the predicted final <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> compares with the measured final <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> in the historical data.\n3.  If the error between the predicted and actual stream PSDs is high, then replace the D 50 equation in the Nageswararao model with a new equation that directly correlates D 50 with Bond [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) Work Index. Use historical data and determine the site-specific slope and intercept:\\]\n\nD 50 = 0.0293 x<b title=\"Bond Work Index\">BWI</b> - 0.3814.\n\n[Flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) Model[](#Flotation_Model)\n------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nAn empirical liberation model developed by the site metallurgists was made available to CRC ORE. This model predicts recovery based on the [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> P 80 size, the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model) recovery and mill <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> .\n\nThe model was modified by CRC ORE to improve the predictions accuracy by adding elemental head grade.\n\nIntegrating the Mine Value Flowsheet[](#Integrating_the_Mine_Value_Flowsheet)\n-----------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\n  \n  \n  \n \n\nThe various survey datasets used for the development of individual process models should ideally correspond to the same ore campaign and time window to ensure a smooth integration. If datasets correspond to different time windows, individual models are to be adjusted so they can match performance for any available campaign dataset, as closely as possible.\n\n2\\. Mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) flowsheet Fine Tuning and Validation[](#Mine_value_chain_flowsheet_Fine_Tuning_and_Validation)\n================================================================================================================================================================\n\nThe historical processing data available is split into two different, and long enough, periods of time, i.e. 12 months each. The first set is used for the integrated <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> fine tuning, whereas the second set is reserved for the <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> validation.\n\nPreliminary Simulations[](#Preliminary_Simulations)\n---------------------------------------------------\n\nThe <b title=\"Selected benchmark for comparison to.\">base case</b> <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> is used to conduct preliminary simulations for the same day-to-day <b title=\"Parameters that define resistance to different comminution types.\">ore hardness</b> parameters and blast designs as in the historical processing data of the first period.\n\nComparison[](#Comparison)\n-------------------------\n\nThe results of these preliminary simulations are compared against the historical processing data for the first period for both <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> and final <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> ([cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) P 80 ).\n\nFlowsheet Fine Tuning[](#Flowsheet_Fine_Tuning)\n-----------------------------------------------\n\nComparison shows that some fine tuning is required. This involves the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) & [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) models.\n\n [![IES FineTuning](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316133/wikiore/69.jpg)](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316133/wikiore/69.jpg) \n\nValidation[](#Validation)\n-------------------------\n\nOnce the <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> has been fine-tunned with the first set of historical processing data, the <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> is tested for the second set of historical processing data, as part of the entire mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> validation.\n\nSimulations[](#Simulations)\n===========================\n\nIES has the capabilities to conduct simulations across the entire mine[value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) for a range of <b title=\"General term for equipment performance parameters.\">operating conditions</b> and <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> . Two types of simulations were conducted:\n\n*   [Grade Engineering](/pages/wikiore-introduction-to-grade-engineering) (GE):\n    *   [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) (ND)\n    *   [differential blasting](/pages/wikiore-induced-deportment) (DB)\n*   <b title=\"Optimisation of fragmentation from blasting to comminution.\">mine-to-mill</b> (<b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b>)\n\n[![IES ExampleScenarios](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316134/wikiore/70.jpg)](https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1687316134/wikiore/70.jpg)\n\nSimulations in[IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) require the setup of the Optimizer functionality to run in-line with the simulations to represent the action taken by plant operators to accommodate the changes in hardness and size of the fresh <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> , while maintaining final product specifications and a stable operation as much as possible.\n\nIn the In-line Optimizer it is required to define:\n\n*   ‘Goal’ and ‘Type’\n*   ‘Parameters’ and their ‘Steps’\n*   ‘Constraints’ and their ‘Ranges’\n\nThe Goal is typically to maximise the operation “<b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> ’. The simulations will be conducted for all possible combinations of the defined ‘Parameters’, and for each of their defined step values. These ‘Parameters’ correspond to input variables to the models. The ‘Constraints’ correspond to outputs from the models that have to fall in the defined ranges.\n\nGE - [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) (ND)[](#GE_-_natural_deportment_ND_)\n-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\n[GE simulations](/sub-topics/strategy-evaluation) are conducted on those blocks in the [block model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_resource_estimation#Resource_block_model) with proven [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment), as indicated by their RR values, to predict overall mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) performance including <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> and ore upgrade for all combinations of three blast intensities and three pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s. Each combination leads to a <b title=\"Relative proportion of feed mass in the accept stream after preconcentration.\">mass pull</b> fraction to screen <b title=\"Material below an specified size (generally used to define material that falls through a screen deck).\">undersize</b> , and thus to a SAG <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> size distribution with truncated top size, resulting on increased <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> , reduced SAG power and, more importantly, an ore upgrade that is reflected in the mass of metal produced in the <b title=\"Product generally produced by metal ore mines.\">concentrate</b> .\n\n1.  Incorporate the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> screening module into the [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> to simulate the blocks with ND.\n2.  Define the three <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s. The Medium <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> fragmentation for the most dominant ore <b title=\"Geological, statistical or spatial groupings used for modelling.\">domain</b>s were used to define the three pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s that produce <b title=\"Relative proportion of feed mass in the accept stream after preconcentration.\">mass pull</b> fractions to <b title=\"Material below an specified size (generally used to define material that falls through a screen deck).\">undersize</b> of 20%, 30% and 40%, so called Screen 1, Screen 2 and Screen 3.\n3.  Define the <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate of the material that will be subject to GE. This material will be blended with the fresh material to <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> the [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution)  <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> . Then create an Interceptor at the screen <b title=\"Material below an specified size (generally used to define material that falls through a screen deck).\">undersize</b> in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) to reflect that consistently for all scenarios.\n4.  The following <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> scenarios, based on the combination of three blast intensities and three pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s, with a common <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> of 210 microns, were simulated in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) for every single ore of interest. The blast intensities are reflected in the <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b>ing the [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution)  <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> , referred as <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> size:\n    *   Medium<b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 1\n    *   Medium <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 2\n    *   Medium <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 3\n    *   Fine <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 1\n    *   Fine <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 2\n    *   Fine <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 3\n    *   Extra Fine <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 1\n    *   Extra Fine <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 2\n    *   Extra Fine <b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> – Screen 3\n5.  Set up the <b title=\"IES specific term for repeated simulations within a section of a circuit.\">in-line optimiser</b> :\n    *   The Fresh <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate (tph) was selected as the ‘Goal’. The Type is set as ‘Maximise’.\n    *   The following operating variables, that are inputs to the models, were selected as ‘Parameters’:\n        *   Main <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> – Medium: <1,000<b title=\"Tonnes per hour\">tph</b> – 3,605 tph>. Steps of 20 tph.\n        *   [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) water addition: Required %Sol <40% - 70%>. Steps of 0.3%.\n        *   Cyc 1 # Units . Steps of 1.\n        *   Cyc 2 # Units . Steps of 1.\n    *   The following operating variables, that are outputs from the models, were selected as ‘Constraints’:\n        *   Cyc1 Pressure\n        *   Cyc2 Pressure\n        *   Circulating Load <150% - 600%>\n        *   Cyc Water combined volumetric flowrate <100 m3/h – 24,000 m3/h>\n        *   [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) Final Product P 80 size <0.200 mm – 0.220 mm>\n        *   Final Product % Sol <32% -38%>\n        *   [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) Total Load <18%-28.14%>\n\nGE - [differential blasting](/pages/wikiore-induced-deportment) (DB)[](#GE_-_differential_blasting_DB_)\n-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\n[differential blasting](/pages/wikiore-induced-deportment) involves a preferential concentration of explosive energy on the high-grade zones on those ores with proven natural [metal deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment), where further [metal deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) can be promoted and thus greater ore upgrades. Therefore, a second pass<b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> simulation is conducted on these selected ores, this time using<b title=\"Differential Blasting\">DB</b> techniques with the Medium<b title=\"Run of mine\">ROM</b> size as the basis. The following steps were followed:\n\n1.  Select the ores that are candidates for DB.\n2.  Create a copy of the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> – [ND](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) where the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> – <b title=\"Differential Blasting\">DB</b> simulations will be conducted. This includes the same three pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s, and the same <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate of the material subject to GE.\n3.  The following <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> scenarios, with <b title=\"Differential Blasting\">DB</b> and three pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s, with a common <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> of 210 microns, were simulated in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) for every <b title=\"A spatially constrained unit within the resource model.\">block</b> of interest:\n    *   DB – Screen 1\n    *   DB – Screen 2\n    *   DB – Screen 3\n4.  Set up in-line optimizer in the same way as GE- ND\n\nMine-to-Mill (M2M)[](#Mine-to-Mill_M2M_)\n----------------------------------------\n\n<b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> is a process integration approach to maximise productivity by evaluating the impact of <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> on overall performance including <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> .  <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> simulations are conducted for the combinations of three blast intensities and three target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b>s, for every single ore of interest. The relevant <b title=\"General properties of rock (grade, hardness, grain size etc…).\">ore characteristics</b> include <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> and Bond BMWI.\n\nThe following steps were followed:\n\n1.  Set up the [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) <b title=\"A specific design within IES or a given circuit configuration.\">flowsheet</b> for the <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> simulations.\n2.  The following scenarios consisting on the combinations of three blast intensities and three target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b>s were simulated for every single ore of interest. The blast intensities are reflected in the <b title=\"Distribution of rock created through the application of explosives.\">blast fragmentation</b> <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b>ing the [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution)  <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> , referred as F; whereas the grind <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> is referred as P:\n    *   <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> F – <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> P\n    *   <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> F – Medium P\n    *   <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> F – Fine P\n    *   Medium F – <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> P\n    *   Medium F – Medium P\n    *   Medium F – Fine P\n    *   Fine F – <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> P\n    *   Fine F – Medium P\n    *   Fine F – Fine P\n3.  Set up the In-line Optimizer:\n    *   The Goal is typically to maximise the overall operation “<b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> ’. The following input variables were selected as ‘Parameters’:\n        *   Fresh <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> rate: <2,000<b title=\"Tonnes per hour\">tph</b> – 4,605 tph>. Steps of 20 tph.\n        *   Pre-crusher <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> : <0 – 180 tph>. Steps of 20 tph.\n        *   [cyclone](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocyclone) Water addition: Required %Sol <40% - 70%>. Steps of 0.3%.\n        *   Cyc 1 # Units . Steps of 1.\n        *   Cyc 2 # Units . Steps of 1.\n    *   The following output variables were selected as ‘Constraints’:\n        *   Cyc1 Pressure\n        *   Cyc2 Pressure\n        *   Circulating Load <150% - 600%>\n        *   Cyc Water combined volumetric flowrate <100 m3/h – 24,000 m3/h>\n        *   [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) Final Product P 80 size <0.170 mm – 0.190 mm>. This range needs to be changed accordingly for every target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> simulated.\n        *   Final Product % Sol <32% -38%>\n        *   [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) Total Load <18%-28.14%>\n\nSimulation Results Sanity Check[](#Simulation_Results_Sanity_Check)\n-------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nDepending on the number of ‘combinations’ simulated, whether blast intensities vs target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b>s (<b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> ), or blast intensities vs pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b>s (GE), and the number of ore types simulated, the[IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) simulation results can become a large amount of data and hence challenging to handle and analyse for consistency. The following procedure is proposed for a ‘quick check’ for consistency.\n\n### Mine-to-Mill (M2M)[](#Mine-to-Mill_M2M__2)\n\nThe results of the <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> simulations can be checked for consistency for every single scenario simulated. The following steps were followed:\n\n1.  List the scenarios simulated. Refer to bullet ‘b’ in Section 6.3. Saving each scenario as an individual file is recommended.\n2.  Rank the <b title=\"Parameters that define resistance to different comminution types.\">ore hardness</b> parameter for the resistance to impact breakage (<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> or SPI) in ascending or descending order, expanding the selection for the entire dataset. Then group the ores for specific hardness parameter ranges. At this site <b title=\"SAG Power Index\">SPI</b> values were used, and the ores were grouped in three ranges for SPI: , and . Make sure there is enough population of blocks within each group.\n3.  Take averages for <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> , <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> size (F 80 ), <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> (P 80 ), and Cu [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) recovery, within each hardness parameter (<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> or SPI) range, and for every single scenario simulated.\n4.  Plot ‘Average hardness parameter (<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> or SPI)’ vs ‘Average <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> ’, for every single scenario simulated. The average hardness parameter corresponds to the average hardness parameter within each hardness range.\n5.  All the nine curves ‘‘Average hardness parameter (<b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> or SPI)’ vs ‘Average <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> ’, corresponding to the nine scenarios simulated, can be visualized in two ways of three graphs of three curves each:\n    *   One single blast intensity, with the three target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b>s as series.\n    *   One single target <b title=\"Resulting material size post comminution stage.\">product size</b> , with the three blast intensities as series.\n6.  The following trends are expected to be observed:\n    *   The higher the resistance to impact breakage (low <b title=\"Resulting output of impact breakage testing.\">axb</b> or high SPI), the lower the <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> . \n    *   Higher <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b>s for the <b title=\"Subjective term for the larger sized component of feed\">coarse</b> r target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b>s, within each blast intensity.\n\nA more detailed tutorial on how to conduct this sanity check in both Excel and [Power BI](https://powerbi.microsoft.com/en-au/) is included in the Appendix.\n\n### GE - [natural deportment](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) (ND)[](#GE_-_natural_deportment_ND__2)\n\nThe results of the [GE simulations](/sub-topics/strategy-evaluation) on ores with[ND](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) can be checked for consistency for every single scenario simulated. The following steps were followed:\n\n1.  List the scenarios simulated. Refer to bullet ‘d’ in Section 6.1. Saving each scenario as an individual file is recommended.\n2.  Rank the ores by grade (ascending or descending order) expanding the selection for the entire dataset. Then group the blocks for specific Cu head grade ranges. At this site the five Cu head grade ranges were: <0.055%-0.15%>, <0.15%-0.30%>, <0.30%-0.45%>, <0.45%-0.60%> and <+0.6%>. Make sure there is enough population of blocks within each group.\n3.  Take averages for <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> , Cu grade in [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation)  <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> (after the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> ore upgrade), and Cu [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) recovery, within each Cu head grade range group, and for every single scenario simulated.\n4.  Estimate the tonnes of Cu in the <b title=\"Product generally produced by metal ore mines.\">concentrate</b> using the above averages, for each Cu head grade range group and for every single scenario simulated. This number is to be used to assess the benefit of <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> for every single scenario simulated.\n5.  Plot ‘average grade, %Cu’ vs ‘average tonnes of Cu produced in the <b title=\"Product generally produced by metal ore mines.\">concentrate</b> ’ for every single scenario simulated, within each blast intensity. The average grade of Cu corresponds to the average Cu grade of each grade range group.\n6.  The following trends are expected to be observed:\n    *   Linear relationship between the Cu head grade and the tonnes of Cu produced in the <b title=\"Product generally produced by metal ore mines.\">concentrate</b> .\n    *   The smaller the pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b> , the greater the benefit of GE, within each blast intensity.\n    *   The higher the blast intensity (finer ROM), the smaller the benefit of GE.\n7.  Compare the<b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> - [ND](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) simulation results with those from the equivalent <b title=\"Mine to Mill\">M2M</b> scenario, i.e. same blast intensity and same target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> .\n\n### GE - [differential blasting](/pages/wikiore-induced-deportment)ing (DB)[](#GE_-_differential_blastinging_DB_)\n\nThe results of the [GE simulations](/sub-topics/strategy-evaluation) on ores where the[ND](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) can be further promoted through<b title=\"Differential Blasting\">DB</b> can also be checked for consistency for every single scenario simulated. The following steps were followed:\n\n1.  List the scenarios simulated. Refer to bullet ‘c’ in Section 6.2. Saving each scenario as an individual file is recommended.\n2.  Since only around 30 % of the blocks with [ND](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) were selected to simulate the effect of DF, new Cu head grades ranges might need to be defined.  So, rank the selected blocks by grade (ascending or descending order) expanding the selection for the entire dataset. Then group the blocks for specific Cu head grade ranges. At this site the five Cu head grade ranges of the ores selected for <b title=\"Differential Blasting\">DB</b> simulations were: <0.055%-0.45%>, <0.45%-0.53%>, <0.53%-0.60%>, <0.60%-0.68%> and <+0.68%>. These ranges were defined so there is enough population of blocks within each group.\n3.  Take averages for <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> , Cu Grade in [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation)  <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> (after the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> ore upgrade), and Cu [flotation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froth_flotation) recovery, within each Cu head grade range group, and for every single scenario simulated.\n4.  Estimate the tonnes of Cu in the <b title=\"Product generally produced by metal ore mines.\">concentrate</b> using the average values above, for each Cu head grade range group and for every single scenario simulated. This number is to be used to assess the benefit of <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> for every single scenario simulated.\n5.  Plot ‘average grade, %Cu’ vs ‘average tonnes of Cu production in the <b title=\"Product generally produced by metal ore mines.\">concentrate</b> ’ for every single scenario simulated. The average grade of Cu corresponds to the average Cu grade of each grade range group.\n6.  The following trends are expected to be observed:\n    *   Linear relationship between the Cu head grade and the Cu production in the <b title=\"Product generally produced by metal ore mines.\">concentrate</b> .\n    *   The smaller the pre-concentration <b title=\"Minimum dimension at which material will be retained as oversize.\">screen aperture</b> , the greater the benefit of <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> at each blast intensity.\n\nCompare the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> -<b title=\"Differential Blasting\">DB</b> simulation results with those from the <b title=\"Grade Engineering\">GE</b> –[ND](/pages/wikiore-natural-deportment) scenario on the same ores, for the same blast intensity and same target <b title=\"Target product size post grind.\">grind size</b> .\n\nSome [Site-Specifics](Site-Specifics)[](#Some_Site-Specifics)\n=============================================================\n\nThis section describes the process models developed by the CRC ORE and the participants to address processes that could not be modelled using the conventional models available.\n\nPre-[crushing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusher) Model[](#Pre-crushing_Model)\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nAt this site, pre-crushed material is fed to the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)s, every time spare capacity in the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)ing <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> is available, caused by the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) becoming the bottleneck of the <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> .\n\nIn order to develop an integrated model in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) for the entire mine [value chain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_chain) at this site, it was necessary to establish a criterion to determine when and by how much the pre-crushed material is added to the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> . This indicates the available capacity in the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> for the pre-crushed material. \n\n\\[|Two criteria have been developed for this purpose:\\]\n\n*   In-line constraint management functionality in IES.\n*   A site-specific power-based model developed by Morrell.\n\nThe optimiser was set up to be “conservative” and pick the lowest of the two as the final pre-crush <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> .\n\n### In-Line Optimiser in IES[](#In-Line_Optimiser_in_IES)\n\nThe <b title=\"IES specific term for repeated simulations within a section of a circuit.\">in-line optimiser</b> in[IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) was used as a constraint manager to incorporate the logic to determine when (for what ores), and at what rate, the pre-crushed material is to be added to the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)s.\n\nThe following were the steps followed:\n\n1.  Create an ‘Expression’ in [IES](https://www.crcore.org.au/ies) for ‘total <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> ’ which is made up of ‘fresh <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> ’ plus the pre-crushed material added to the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)s, with the following relationship:    ‘Total <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> ’=1000x’Fresh <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> ’ + ‘Pre-crushed material’.\n2.  When setting up the <b title=\"IES specific term for repeated simulations within a section of a circuit.\">in-line optimiser</b> in IES, use this Expression as the ‘Goal’ and the type as ‘Maximise’. By maximising this expression, priority will be given to maximise <b title=\"Tonnes per hour\">tph</b> in the SAG first (Fresh <b title=\"Material entering a predetermined system.\">feed</b> ) due to the weight (x1000) assigned to it in the expression. Any spare capacity in the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)s will be filled up with pre-crushed material until the maximum [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)ing capacity is reached as per the “Constraints’ defined in the <b title=\"IES specific term for repeated simulations within a section of a circuit.\">in-line optimiser</b> .\n\n### Morrell Model[](#Morrell_Model)\n\nThe Morrell methodology is used to estimate the Specific [comminution](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comminution) Energy (<b title=\"KiloWattHours per tonne\">kWh/t</b> ) that is required for a duty, i.e. given <b title=\"General term for a collection of comminution/flotation equipment.\">circuit</b> configuration, <b title=\"Parameters that define resistance to different comminution types.\">ore hardness</b> and size reduction. This calculated specific energy is used by AAC in conjunction with the maximum installed power for [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill) and [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)s, to determine individual SAG and [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill) maximum <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b>s separately. If the [SAG mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mill_%28grinding%29#SAG_mill)  <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> is lower than the [ball mill](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_mill)’s, then spare capacity is available for the pre-crushed material which is the difference between these two <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b>s. The <b title=\"Metric for overall tonnage moving through a system within a  specified time.\">throughput</b> is capped to the maximum capacity of the pre-crusher module."},"organisations":[],"embeds":{"citations":[],"imageAssets":[]},"video":null,"banner":null,"fileAssets":[],"citations":[],"feedEntries":[],"posts":[],"moderators":[]}}},"pageContext":{"lang":{"id":"en","path":"","iso":"en","name":"English","label":"English"},"availableEntities":["Catalyst","CommodityGroup","Innovation","Organisation","Page","Person","Post","SubTopic","Topic","Trend","OrganisationType","HorizonType","Economy","FeedEntry","Video","Citation","Objective","ProfileType","ExpertiseLevel"],"detailEntities":["Catalyst","CommodityGroup","Innovation","Organisation","Page","Person","Post","SubTopic","Topic","Trend"],"site":{"id":"65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","slug":"connect-ore","name":"ConnectOre","url":"https://connectore.org","title":"ConnectOre","twitter":null,"threads":null,"facebook":null,"linkedin":null,"instagram":null,"flickr":null,"tiktok":null,"youtube":null,"ownerName":"ICAA","recaptchaKey":"6LfG2J0qAAAAAHDCFfJnrWOj6DiWJGik5BAa_7p8","googleSiteVerification":null,"platformName":"ConnectOre","platformUrl":"https://platform.connectore.org","supportEmail":null,"contactEmail":null,"mainMenu":{"id":"65d2edaaebf7bb9388ffaf79","slug":"website-navigation"},"linearMenu":null,"entityViews":[{"id":"67528c24c135ebcfc668f1ba_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Value Chain","hash":"value-chain","label":null,"slug":"value-chain","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"6752a61b8b51dfa7b77b1e37","name":"Connections Navigator Icon Glyph","slug":"connections-navigator-icon-glyph","component":"ConnectionsNavigatorIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"6667fa4ff794dd6e045135c1","name":"Value Chain Theme","internalName":"Trend"},{"id":"6667fa58f794dd6e045135c6","name":"Topic","internalName":"Topic"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"6757ef1ede8adbd45cf19474_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Bulletin Board","hash":"bulletin-board","label":null,"slug":"bulletin-board","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"681c2cebbccc5a72d8382f31","name":"Tag Icon","slug":"tag-icon","component":"TagDotIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"67528d88c135ebcfc668f31b_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Innovations","hash":"innovations","label":null,"slug":"innovations","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"67528cddc135ebcfc668f304","name":"Grid Icon Glyph","slug":"grid-icon-glyph","component":"GridIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"67528d74c135ebcfc668f315","name":"Innovation","internalName":"innovation"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"67625640fbc7c50d8644c592_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Community","hash":"community","label":null,"slug":"community","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"67528cddc135ebcfc668f304","name":"Grid Icon Glyph","slug":"grid-icon-glyph","component":"GridIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"67528404c135ebcfc668ee1c","name":"Person","internalName":"Person"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"67528e1bc135ebcfc668f33a_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Stakeholder Map","hash":"stakeholder-map","label":null,"slug":"stakeholder-map","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"67528cddc135ebcfc668f304","name":"Grid Icon Glyph","slug":"grid-icon-glyph","component":"GridIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"66680141f794dd6e0451367a","name":"Organisation","internalName":"Organisation"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]},{"id":"67529040c135ebcfc668f4ae_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"References","hash":"references","label":null,"slug":"references","count":0,"showCount":null,"disabled":null,"icon":{"id":"67528cddc135ebcfc668f304","name":"Grid Icon Glyph","slug":"grid-icon-glyph","component":"GridIconGlyph"},"childEntityTypes":[{"id":"6752902fc135ebcfc668f4a4","name":"Article","internalName":"FeedEntry"},{"id":"67529039c135ebcfc668f4aa","name":"Citation","internalName":"Citation"},{"id":"67528de9c135ebcfc668f328","name":"Catalyst","internalName":"catalyst"},{"id":"67528df9c135ebcfc668f32d","name":"Page","internalName":"page"}],"type":{"id":"67528b63c135ebcfc668f19c","name":"Explorer","slug":"explorer"},"slices":[]}],"entityAppViews":[],"entityOnboardingViews":[{"id":"680c3a4ebc80e4d0f3cfa2ef_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Trend Expertise Step","hash":"trend-expertise-step","label":null,"slug":"trend-expertise-step","count":0,"showCount":null,"icon":null,"childEntityTypes":[],"type":{"id":"680c394fbc80e4d0f3cfa2d8","name":"Onboarding","slug":"onboarding"},"slices":[{"id":"680c39f2bc80e4d0f3cfa2e0_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Trend Expertise Onboarding Grid","slug":"trend-expertise-onboarding-grid","label":null,"updated":"2025-04-26T01:42:10.20","layout":{"id":"680c3993bc80e4d0f3cfa2dd","name":"Slice Onboarding Trend Expertise Grid","slug":"slice-onboarding-trend-expertise-grid","component":"SliceLayoutOnboardingTrendExpertiseGrid"},"connectedEntities":[],"headerFontType":null,"pretitle":null,"pretitleRich":{"id":"680c39f2bc80e4d0f3cfa2e0_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_pretitleRich","text":""},"title":null,"titleRich":{"id":"680c39f2bc80e4d0f3cfa2e0_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_titleRich","text":"Are you **an industry expert** in any of these Value Chain Themes?"}}]},{"id":"680c3a85bc80e4d0f3cfa2fa_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Profile Types Step","hash":"profile-types-step","label":null,"slug":"profile-types-step","count":0,"showCount":null,"icon":null,"childEntityTypes":[],"type":{"id":"680c394fbc80e4d0f3cfa2d8","name":"Onboarding","slug":"onboarding"},"slices":[{"id":"680c3a82bc80e4d0f3cfa2f7_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Profile Types Onboarding Grid","slug":"profile-types-onboarding-grid","label":null,"updated":"2025-04-26T01:44:34.63","layout":{"id":"680c3a13bc80e4d0f3cfa2e4","name":"Slice Onboarding Profile Types Grid","slug":"slice-onboarding-profile-types-grid","component":"SliceLayoutOnboardingProfileTypesGrid"},"connectedEntities":[],"headerFontType":null,"pretitle":null,"pretitleRich":{"id":"680c3a82bc80e4d0f3cfa2f7_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_pretitleRich","text":""},"title":"Which best describes you?","titleRich":{"id":"680c3a82bc80e4d0f3cfa2f7_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_titleRich","text":""}}]},{"id":"680c3aaabc80e4d0f3cfa2ff_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Objectives Step","hash":"objectives-step","label":null,"slug":"objectives-step","count":0,"showCount":null,"icon":null,"childEntityTypes":[],"type":{"id":"680c394fbc80e4d0f3cfa2d8","name":"Onboarding","slug":"onboarding"},"slices":[{"id":"680c3aa8bc80e4d0f3cfa2fc_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df","name":"Objectives Onboarding Grid","slug":"objectives-onboarding-grid","label":null,"updated":"2025-04-26T01:45:12.76","layout":{"id":"680c3a3fbc80e4d0f3cfa2ea","name":"Slice Onboarding Objectives Grid","slug":"slice-onboarding-objectives-grid","component":"SliceLayoutOnboardingObjectivesGrid"},"connectedEntities":[],"headerFontType":null,"pretitle":null,"pretitleRich":{"id":"680c3aa8bc80e4d0f3cfa2fc_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_pretitleRich","text":""},"title":"What are your priority objectives?","titleRich":{"id":"680c3aa8bc80e4d0f3cfa2fc_65d2edd1ebf7bb9388ffb0df_titleRich","text":""}}]}],"gptLanguages":[{"id":"65d2eda5ebf7bb9388ffaf1f","name":"English","slug":"english","iso":"en","locale":"en_US","path":"/en","label":"English","menuLabel":null},{"id":"666f70b6e051ad9ef086d1be","name":"Arabic","slug":"arabic","iso":"ar","locale":"ar_AE","path":"/ar","label":"عربي","menuLabel":null},{"id":"666f7161e051ad9ef086d1c4","name":"Spanish","slug":"spanish","iso":"es","locale":"es_ES","path":"/es","label":"español","menuLabel":null},{"id":"666f71c9e051ad9ef086d1c8","name":"German","slug":"german","iso":"de","locale":"de_DE","path":"/de","label":"Deutsch","menuLabel":null},{"id":"65d2eda5ebf7bb9388ffaf20","name":"French","slug":"french","iso":"fr","locale":"fr_FR","path":"/fr","label":"Français","menuLabel":null}],"gptQuestionTemplate":{"id":"662c7f6e81ef1920e3638518","name":"Standard Open Question","slug":"standard-open-question","path":"/prompt-templates/standard-open-question","__typename":"PromptTemplate","_entityTypeName":null,"label":"CopperAI","type":{"id":"662c7f1981ef1920e363850f","name":"Ask","slug":"ask"},"description":{"text":"This template is tailored for providing accurate responses based on specific context. It integrates contextual details from \"contextual information\" and addresses the \"target question\". The response is always in English, prioritizing clarity. If the answer is unknown, the template openly acknowledges this, ensuring honesty and avoiding speculation. This format is ideal for precise, context-sensitive, and truthful answering."},"summary":{"text":"Ask a general question about Website content"},"gptModel":{"id":"67564c4f2f6749787d0e03dc","name":"OpenAI GPT 4o","slug":"open-ai-gpt-4-o","dataSetId":"openai:gpt-4o"},"variablesPrompt":{"text":""},"submitLabel":"Ask","languages":[],"icon":{"id":"67528b9cc135ebcfc668f1a3","name":"AI Lower Case Icon Glyph","slug":"ai-lower-case-icon-glyph","component":"AiLowerCaseIconGlyph"},"variables":[{"id":"6668076bf794dd6e045138d9","name":"question","slug":"question","useVectorStore":true,"label":"What would you like to know?","labelAnother":null,"help":{"text":""},"options":{"text":""},"defaultValue":null,"entityTypes":[],"controlType":{"id":"6667ff19f794dd6e04513656","name":"Textarea","slug":"textarea"},"labelContextual":null,"labelAnotherContextual":null,"helpContextual":{"text":""},"optionsContextual":{"text":""},"defaultValueContextual":null,"entityTypesContextual":[],"controlTypeContextual":{"id":"6667ff19f794dd6e04513656","name":"Textarea","slug":"textarea"}}]},"advertisements":[],"logoVerticalOffset":null,"logoHorizontalOffset":null,"logoVerticalOffsetMobile":null,"logoHorizontalOffsetMobile":null,"logoVerticalOffsetTablet":null,"logoHorizontalOffsetTablet":null,"logoVerticalOffsetDesktop":null,"logoHorizontalOffsetDesktop":null,"logoHeightMobile":44,"logoHeightTablet":null,"logoHeightDesktop":null,"headerHeightMobile":null,"headerHeightTablet":null,"headerHeightDesktop":null,"logo":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1738807465/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_logo__CopperOre_Master_Brand_Identity-colour_cd4vgg.webp","type":"image/webp","width":945,"height":266},"logoInverted":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1738807452/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_logoInverted__CopperOre_Master_Brand_Identity-white_chnucx.webp","type":"image/webp","width":945,"height":266},"footerMenu":null,"footerSecondaryMenu":null,"footerContent":{"text":"© {year} ConnectOre. All Rights Reserved\n"},"creator":null,"poweredBy":{"id":"65d2edadebf7bb9388ffafc8","name":"Shapeable","slug":"shapeable","url":"https://shapeable.ai","logo":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1674010034/platform/organisation/shapeable_logo__shapeable.png","type":"image/png","width":1174,"height":368},"logoInverted":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1729474494/copper-connect/organisation/shapeable_logoInverted__shapeable-logo-inverted_sdcfpk.png","type":"image/png","width":392,"height":118},"logoSubtle":null},"poweredByLabel":null,"poweredByContent":{"text":""},"explorerPage":{"name":"Explorer","title":null,"slug":"explorer","path":"/explorer"},"termsPage":{"name":"Terms of Use","title":null,"slug":"terms-of-use","path":"/terms-of-use"},"homePage":null,"knowledgeHubPage":{"name":"News","title":null,"slug":"news","path":"/news"},"privacyPolicyPage":{"name":"Privacy Policy","title":null,"slug":"privacy-policy","path":"/privacy-policy"},"summary":{"text":"A platform to accelerate industry-wide innovation through collective intelligence and collaborative action"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1713942350/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_thumbnail__site-thumb_bmicl8.png"},"openGraph":{"title":"ConnectOre","date":"2026-07-31T04:44:47.80","description":{"plain":"A platform to accelerate industry-wide innovation through collective intelligence and collaborative action\n"},"image":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1713942350/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_thumbnail__site-thumb_bmicl8.png","type":"image/png","thumbnails":{"full":{"url":"https://res.cloudinary.com/shapeable/image/upload/v1713942350/copper-connect/site/copper-connect_thumbnail__site-thumb_bmicl8.png"}}}},"termsAndConditions":{"text":""},"privacyPolicy":{"text":"At ConnectOre we respect your privacy. We want to ensure that you get the information, content, and experiences that matter most to you. ConnectOre is committed to protecting the privacy of its stakeholders, communities, and other contacts.\n\n## Scope\n\nThis privacy policy applies to all personal data processed by full-time and part-time employees, volunteers when acting on behalf of ConnectOre contractors and partners doing business on behalf of ConnectOre, as well as all legal entities, all operating locations in all countries, and all business processes conducted by ConnectOre.\n\n## Information Collected\n\n#### What information do we collect?\n\nConnectOre collects the following personal data in line with the use purposes explained in a subsequent section:\n\n  * Your name and contact details\n  * Online profile data/usage\n  * Contact information\n  * Social media profile information\n  * Education and professional information\n  * Registration and participation in ConnectOre events and activities \n  * Information about service usage\n  * Cookies\n  * Authentication data\n  * Location information\n  * Author and peer review information\n  * Other information you upload or provide to us\n\n#### How do we use your information?\n\nConnectOre uses (and, where specified, shares) your personal information for the following purposes:\n\n  * To provide support or other services. ConnectOre may use your personal information to provide you with support or other services that you have ordered or requested. ConnectOre may also use your personal information to respond directly to your requests for information, including registrations for webinars, or other specific requests, or pass your contact information to the appropriate ConnectOre supplier or reseller for further follow-up related to your interests.\n  * To provide information based on your needs and respond to your requests. ConnectOre may use your personal information to provide you with notices of new product releases and service developments.\n  * To administer products. ConnectOre may contact you if you make use of (digital) products we offer, to confirm certain information (for example, that you did not experience problems in a download process). We may also use this information to confirm compliance with licensing and other terms of use and may share it with your company/institution.\n  * To assist in your participation in ConnectOre activities. ConnectOre will communicate with you, if you are participating in certain ConnectOre activities such as ConnectOre Summit, authoring or reviewing a ConnectOre article, or ConnectOre humanitarian activities. ConnectOre may send you information such as update messages related to those activities (such as but not limited to the event's content, and event logistics)\n  * To update you on relevant ConnectOre events and opportunities. ConnectOre may communicate with you regarding relevant ConnectOre events and opportunities.\n  * To protect ConnectOre content and services. We may use your information to prevent potentially illegal activities and to enforce our terms and conditions.\n  * To get feedback or input from you. In order to deliver products and services of most interest to our stakeholders, from time to time, we may ask you to provide us input and feedback (for example through surveys).\n\n#### How can you control your information?\n\nYou can control the information we have about you and how we use as follows:\n\n  * If you are a registered guest for ConnectOre Annual Summit 2021, any request for review, revise or correction of your personal data can be sent to john.fennell@copper.com.au specifying your request.\n\n#### Personal data about minors and children\n\nConnectOre does not knowingly collect data from or about children under 16 without the permission of parent(s)/guardian(s). If we learn that we have collected personal information from a child under 16, we will delete that information as quickly as possible. If you believe that we might have any information from or about a child under age 16, please contact us.\n\n#### How will you know if the Privacy Policy is changed?\n\nConnectOre may update its Privacy Policy from time to time. If we make any material changes you will be notified by means of a notice on our website prior on the date the change becomes effective. We encourage you to periodically review this page for the latest information on our privacy practices.\n\n## Technical And Regulatory Information\n\n#### Logging practices\n\nConnectOre automatically records the Internet Protocol (IP) addresses of visitors. The IP address is a unique number assigned to every computer on the internet. Generally, an IP address changes each time you connect to the internet (it is a \"dynamic\" address). Note, however, that if you have a broadband connection, depending on your individual circumstance, the IP address that we collect may contain information that could be deemed identifiable. This is because, with some broadband connections, your IP address doesn't change (it is \"static\") and could be associated with your personal computer.\n\nAs well as recording the IP addresses of users, ConnectOre may also keep track of sites that users visited immediately prior to visiting ConnectOre's website and the search terms they used to find it. We keep track of the pages visited on ConnectOre's website, the amount of time spent on those pages and the types of searches done on them. Your searches remain confidential and anonymous. ConnectOre uses this information only for statistical purposes to find out which pages users find most useful and to improve the website.\nConnectOre also captures and stores information that you transmit. This may include:\n\n  * Browser/Device type/version\n  * Operating system used\n  * Media Access Control (MAC) address\n  * Date and time of the server request\n  * Volume of data transferred\n\n#### External links behaviour\n\nSome of the links on ConnectOre's websites link to other sites created and maintained by other public- and/or private-sector organizations. ConnectOre provides these links solely for your information and convenience. When you transfer to an outside website, you are leaving ConnectOre domain, and ConnectOre's information management policies no longer apply. ConnectOre encourages you to read the privacy statement of each external website that you visit before you provide any personal data.\n\n#### Cookies and web beacons\n\nCookies and web beacons are electronic placeholders that are placed on your device by websites to track your individual movements on that website over time. ConnectOre uses both session-based cookies (which last only for the duration of the user's session) and persistent cookies (which remain on your device and provide information about the session you are in and waits for the next time you use that site again).\n\nThese cookies and web beacons provide useful information to ConnectOre, enabling us to recognize repeat users, facilitate the user's access to and use of our sites, allows us to track usage behavior, and to balance the usage of our websites on all ConnectOre web servers.\nTracking cookies, third-party cookies, and other technologies such as web beacons may be used to process additional information, enable non-core functionalities on ConnectOre website and enable third-party functions (such as a social media \"share\" link). We may also include web beacons and other similar technology in promotional email messages to determine whether the messages have been opened.\n\n#### Do Not Track (DNT)\n\nThe online advertising industry has self-regulatory initiatives designed to provide consumers a choice in the types of ads they may see online and to conveniently opt-out from online behavioral ads served by some or all of the companies participating in these programs. Our websites do not respond to DNT consumer browser settings.\n\n#### Responses to legal requests\n\nConnectOre reserves the right to share your information to respond to duly authorized information requests of governmental authorities or where required by law.\n\n#### Your data rights\n\nConnectOre complies with all applicable data privacy laws and regulations including, but not limited to, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). Under these laws and regulations, you may have certain rights to your data. Should you wish to exercise any of these rights, please send an email request to john.fennell@copper.com.au with \"Data Privacy Request'' in the subject line and in the email please identify the specific privacy right you request assistance with. Please note additional information may be requested prior to fulfilling a request and that ConnectOre reserves the right to charge a fee, where permitted, to cover the cost of certain requests.\n\n#### How do I contact you if there is an issue?\nIf you have any questions or concerns about this Privacy Policy or about the use of your personal information, please feel free to contact us by email at john.fennell@copper.com.au"},"welcomeUrl":"https://connectore.org/app/welcome","welcomeTitle":"Welcome to ConnectOre and thanks for joining us! ","invitationAction":"join the ConnectOre community","setupCompletionMessage":null,"languages":[],"brandColors":[],"showLogin":true,"showShareMenu":null,"showFollowMenu":true,"showPlatformLogin":null,"showContactUs":null,"loginLabel":"Explorer Login","platformLoginLabel":"Community Platform","headerButtons":[]},"includeProfile":true,"disableProfileEditing":false,"dynamicEntityTypeNames":["Person","Organisation"],"profilePath":"/app/profile","welcomePath":"/app/welcome","id":"65d2edd7ebf7bb9388ffb16a","slug":"ge-in-ies-methodology","entityPath":"/sub-topics/ge-in-ies-methodology","openGraph":{},"entityTypeName":"SubTopic","name":"GE in IES Methodology","updated":"2024-12-20T03:47:29.59","__type":"SubTopic"}},
    "staticQueryHashes": ["1044227382","1158597448","1242646999","1427075558","1452322194","1520036161","1545705019","1586309863","1606754935","1816168740","1864381666","1903214493","1945056504","1989845544","2034981229","2181044613","2409034939","2463401854","2526615987","2642656775","2862279633","2867243664","2910164142","2912920178","296816903","3073584486","3150399266","3172506128","3320076387","3447680494","3453148481","3624873332","364221563","3692255024","3778988535","3782604890","4091857177","4216505212","591477963","701411134","758936535","80004486","857137463","881103158"]}